Good morning, Britain. I have just watched Channel 4's 'The Great ADHD Myth?' so that you don't have to subject yourself to 45 minutes of throwing things at the television in anger as a 10 year old child is exploited for the nation's entertainment.
Last year, Benjamin T. Sharpe, PhD scanned my brain alongside Presenter Zara McDermott's for a BBC documentary, showing the impact of scrolling on social media on an ADHD vs a non-ADHD brain. You can see the results below and read more about this here.
See, although I am an adult with ADHD and autism, I have the capacity to make this decision. It was my idea to have my brain scanned alongside Zara's, because I suspected the outcomes would be extremely validating for millions of people who are routinely gaslit for attempting to seek help for themselves or the people they care about.
In contrast, the 10 year old boy featured in this documentary, Mason could not provide anything approaching fully informed adult consent for being the subject of an experiment featured on national television (and neither could his brother, who was also featured). In fact, at one point, Mason even jokes that he 'wants a lawyer'.
For me, this was the most disturbing part of a documentary presenting itself as a benevolent challenge to pharmaceutical companies allegedly drugging children into compliance.
In reality, it was a series of editorial decisions arranged to produce a particular conclusion, engineer outrage, and ultimately, make money.
1) The exploitation of vulnerable people
Supposedly credible professionals appear throughout the programme posing philosophical questions about whether ADHD is real, whether diagnosis is invented and whether medication is a form of social control. But Mason's body, behaviour and private life become the evidence.
Intensely personal moments involving Mason and his family - including another child - are made available for public consumption and judgement. Viewers see Mason distressed. They see him hit his brother. They are invited into his home, his school performance, his medication decisions and his relationships.
A 10-year-old and his family become the canvas onto which, between advertising breaks, the programme projects enormous political conclusions about millions of people and the structures of a broken society. Regardless of your views about ADHD, this should concern you.
The programme condemns industries for turning children into objects, while turning a child's private life into commercially funded television content to make their point.
It is a depressing metaphor for the rest of us: the people who literally helped build the system get to judge how we survive within it. Our lived experiences are weaponised by 'experts' in a debate where they write the questions, control the evidence and deliver the verdict.
2) The illusion of consent
As the children's mother, Shauna may have consented to her family’s participation in the programme, but this was never an equal relationship.
On one side was a family seeking help for their child within a broken healthcare system. On the other was a production company working for a broadcaster that reported £1.03 billion in revenue in 2025.
Only one side had the resources to record, edit, distribute and legally defend the finished story. The other side became the content. In situations involving such immense imbalances of power, consent is nothing more than an arbitrary checkbox, enabling the more powerful side to weaponise this later on, if needed.
The presenter, Max Pemberton, explains that Shauna had been filming the children and sending him footage, some of which was broadcast as part of the show.
The programme does not explain who could access this footage, how it was protected or why broadcasting it was necessary. We are not told what either child understood about the recordings, or whether they knew that their most vulnerable moments could later be shown on national television.
There is no shortage of expert jargon expressing concern for children at risk of a 'cultural experiment', but almost nothing about safeguarding the children whose private lives supplied the programme's evidence.
At age 47, Max Pemberton can understand the risks involved in sharing his experiences on national television - but the children being filmed cannot.
3) The illusion of an experiment
The documentary repeatedly describes Mason stopping his ADHD medication for six weeks as an 'experiment'.
However, the adults in his life also changed his access to screens, diet (even being prescribed specific 'nutritional supplements'), outdoor activity, exercise levels, and expectations, as he was being filmed for national television. It is hardly an impartial, groundbreaking scientific breakthrough.
Of course a child may feel happier when receiving more movement, nature, connection and focused time with his family. Why didn't they do this in the first place?
Good question. How many parents have the time, money, safe outdoor space, energy and practical support required to reproduce this intensive intervention indefinitely? The programme makes a temporary, television-supported and paid-for 'transformation' look like an obvious alternative that ordinary families have simply failed to try.
The message to exhausted parents is:
It's your fault that your child needs medication that zaps their personality, because you don't feed them enough vegetables, take them for enough woodland walks, or remove their devices enough.
Many families would love to have the resources to provide all of this. Their inability to do so is evidence of structural inequality - not inadequate parenting. Who wants to pick up their phone 2500 times per day?
The show itself highlights the futility of this attempt, claiming that devices have been removed - whilst Mason is literally made to record video diaries. He even asks the Alexa speaker to set his time limit for his screen time! And of course, we all watch this... through a screen.
4) The illusion of choice
The programme did not simply observe Mason's experience - it gave him a narrative where medication imprisoned his 'true self', removing his 'funness' and dulling his 'sparkle'.
We were not presented with any clinical oversight or review of this 'experiment', or told what kinds of conversations had led up to it. Mason was not asked what mattered the most to him, but he was effectively asked to choose between medication, or 'being yourself'.
This effectively painted his mother, who eventually put him back on medication, as the villain drugging her child, just so that he could get good exam results. In reality, Shauna depicts the genuine paradox that most parents of neurodivergent children live within.
They are caught between the 'experts' who make diagnoses and prescribe medication, the industry of misinformation that has made up the gaps within broken systems, and reality. Somewhere along the way, they might talk to their child, or the teacher, who is obviously just as clueless as they are.
5) The illusion of expertise
The programme repeatedly invokes prestigious titles to make its criticism appear authoritative. Dr Iona Heath is introduced as a former president of the Royal College of General Practitioners, whereas Professor Dinesh Bhugra is a former president of the Royal College of Psychiatrists.
These are not powerless outsiders discovering the medicalisation of ADHD for the first time. They held influential positions within the institutions whose failures they now condemn.
Titles like 'doctor', 'professor', and 'president' express the illusion of credibility, distracting us from the fact that they are literally distancing themselves from the responsibility of the institutions that granted their authority.
They are like the architects standing outside the building, debating whether the cracks are real. Meanwhile, the people living inside must endure the leaking roof and unsafe staircases while repeatedly proving that the structure is harming them. Any scaffolding they might create for themselves is condemned by the architects as exploitation and control.
6) The illusion of science
The show is littered with 'shocking' comments about the legitimacy of ADHD as a medical condition, often by the below esteemed medical professionals. So it's therefore quite ironic that the documentary itself tries an 'experiment' looking at ADHD symptoms.
Here are some questions for the no less than TWELVE medical professionals featured in this 45 minute show:
- Dr Max Pemberton: if ADHD assessments are meaningless and you don't have ADHD, why did you pay for one, accept the prescription, and take the drug on television? What clinical safeguards were in place for your 'experiment' with Mason?
- Katya Rubia: if there are only 'minimal' differences between neuroimaging of ADHD and non-ADHD brains, and it is a cultural definition that we make up as a society, then why and how can your expertise focus on ADHD?
- Lucy Johnstone: if professionals cannot reliably identify ADHD without a brain test, how can a psychologist reliably identify the hidden trauma, meaning or power dynamics explaining the same behaviour? What makes your interpretation more valid than the diagnostic construction you reject?
- Dr Sami Timimi: if ADHD exists only in professionals’ subjective imaginations, what gives you the authority to replace that diagnosis with your own interpretation of a child’s behaviour? Why characterise medication as adult discipline while overlooking a child's improved ability to regulate himself, learn and work independently as benefits they may wish to have as well?
- Professor Dinesh Bhugra: if the ADHD industry profits from people's misery, how did the psychiatric profession you led as President allow and legitimise this industry?
- Dr Iona Heath: if ADHD isn't medical, then why is the medical authority of a doctor who retired from practice 16 years ago being used to support this? If you were to 'abolish the ADHD label' immediately, how would children access support whilst waiting for the educational system you propose?
- Sarah Warley: if profiting from ADHD treatment makes pharmaceutical companies suspect, why doesn't this also apply to your private clinic, tests, supplements, and 'drug-free' treatment? Which biological tests did you perform, are they clinically validated for ADHD, and how did their results determine Mason's treatment?
- Professor Sam Wass: if screens can produce 'ADHD type behaviours' in any child, and nature can temporarily reduce them, how do you distinguish these environmental effects from persistent ADHD? And why would symptom improvement disprove an entire underlying condition rather than demonstrate that environment can intensify or relieve it?
- Dr Sanah Ahsan: if the average person touches their phone 2,500 times per day, how does this demonstrate anything specific about ADHD, rather than modern attention generally?
- Professor Matthew Smith: if pharmaceutical marketing created the ADHD industry, are you neutral if you are the author of a book on the controversy surrounding ADHD?
- Dr Courtney Raspin: if difficulties involving normal human traits shouldn’t be medicalised or professionally accommodated, why do you run a clinic treating difficulties involving normal human traits? And why is personalised support compassionate when provided in your clinic, but an unjustified privilege when provided to a child with ADHD in a theme park setting?
- Dr Chris Bagley: you frame ADHD medication as changing children for the school system’s convenience, but how do you account for Mason’s own frustration when he struggled to complete work he had previously been capable of doing? Doesn’t that suggest the medication may have benefited him, not merely his teachers?
Either it's real, or it's not. A social construct, or a disorder. Behaviour, or an experience. They can't have their cake and eat it.
Concern is expressed over the potential medicalisation of children as a form of social control in schools. Ironically, this entire show is effectively an advertisement for ADHD coaching, as it is highlighting the importance of our environment, as opposed to 'problems' inherent within individuals needing to be fixed.
However, whether the 'problem' is with the individual or their environment, the point is that something needs to change. Pills don't give skills: that is correct. Is that the fault of the people who trust their doctor's advice, and are left to figure out the rest by themselves? Or of those who have tried all of the support and techniques they could find, but still feel 'broken', as though nothing works for them like it does for other people?
7)The illusion of 'treatment'
As a psychiatrist, Max Pemberton could diagnose ADHD himself, if he wanted to. He clearly knows the processes involved, which makes it even more peculiar that he decided to undergo a £1200 online assessment, despite saying that he doesn't believe he has ADHD.
Interestingly, what did make it into this 45 minute programme, was Max being asked if he was comfortable having the experience filmed. He very gallantly asked the production crew to leave the room, but tells them to leave the camera behind.
As the presenter, Max would have been well aware of the camera set up involved in capturing this footage. We are not told why he feels comfortable having his assessment filmed by a camera, but no humans. If 10 year old Mason was offered the same level of dignity, it certainly didn't make it into the final cut.
Meanwhile, this supposedly confidential clinical encounter is consciously preserved for television. Although, because he wears headphones, we cannot hear the clinician. We do not know what information he provided, what the full assessment covered, or how his prescription for medication was obtained. And so, we'll just have to take his word for it.
Max takes one dose of the medication and reports feeling less like himself, notably whilst in a shop where he usually would have been more talkative with strangers. I would also guess that he is not normally followed around with a camera and television crew whilst shopping.
This singular experience is used to validate the programme's narrative around Mason: medication removes the qualities that 'make me me'. Whilst Max is able to completely control his testing environment (despite having full knowledge of the realities of titration periods and routine ECG testing beforehand), Mason is the material being interpreted.
I don't think Max is a brave martyr for tricking his peers into diagnosing him with ADHD, or for trying a pill and expectantly filming the outcome. I think it is a waste of clinical resources in the name of entertainment.
8)The illusion of a 'story'
Bizarrely, one of the things that made me most angry whilst watching this documentary was the 'story' that was woven in the background. For the first part, footage of Mason only shows him distressed, aggressive, or looking into screens of devices that he was using. His mum and brother are introduced, but not his dad.
When the 'experiment' starts, we see the end of the first week with a bunch of red roses presented to Shauna. Conveniently, this is filmed for content, even though she is told to close her eyes. And then we meet her partner, who's rewarding her for her 'difficult week'.
Her partner becomes a curious narrator in this story arc. He features in forest walks and shares how he's only known Mason on medication, so since he's been off it, he's been able to see his 'true self'. He says how Mason has made him laugh more in those weeks than all of the time that he knew him before then. How will Mason feel watching this back in 5 or 10 years?
After the children are presented collecting and presenting their devices and food to the stranger who literally locks their medication in a box for dramatic effect, the background narrative around them changes. During the experiment and beyond, we are only shown footage of a loving, happy family in the forest - no screens in sight.
The interview with Mason's teacher is probably the most balanced part of the programme, despite her being asked deliberately provocative questions such as 'are children who take ADHD medication easier to teach?'. Miss Jenkins shared her observations without forcing them into a simplistic pro- or anti-medication narrative. She acknowledged that Mason was more sociable and expressive without medication, while also explaining that he found self-regulation more exhausting and struggled to work independently. These were potential benefits and costs for Mason - not just questions of teacher convenience.
Compare all of this build up with the anti-climatic ending that pops up in text on a screen. After Mason's symptoms affected his schoolwork, his mum made the 'difficult decision' to put him back on his medication. The evidence supporting the programme’s argument was the real story, but the evidence complicating it was just text on a screen.
And what do we think the first thing the viewer will do will be after watching this abrupt ending, processing the fact that they just wasted 45 minutes of their life that they will never get back, and what about that poor little kid who's being drugged to perform academically?
They will turn to the internet and express their outrage. Most likely, it will be aimed at the villain who is apparently drugging the humour and 'sparkle' out of her child so that he can get good exam results. It's always mum's fault.
ADHD does not have to be a defect to be real
The programme almost reaches the right conclusion: perhaps children and adults alike do not need their brains 'fixed'. Perhaps, the systems they are expected to survive within need to change.
Congratulations. Neurodivergent people have been saying this for decades.
The opposite of pathologising ADHD is not denying that it exists. It is believing people when they describe their own experiences, however they are labelled.
It is understanding that medication can be liberating, harmful, unnecessary - or some complicated combination of those things - depending on the person.
It is recognising that different people will struggle in different situations. It is simply accepting the fact that one size does not fit all, and that people think differently to one another.
I don't need to be able to point to neuroscience to believe my own experiences, because I don't have a choice. I live them every day. It seems to be people like the 'experts' featured in this documentary that have a problem with the way that some people exist in the world - not us.
In one way, I felt extremely happy watching this pathetic excuse for a documentary, because it has validated the approaches that I have based ADHD Works coaching, supervision and frameworks on.
These approaches are not designed to coach someone into being 'normal', or more palatable to the people around them. They are designed to help people to understand who they as an entirely unique individual are, the ways that their brain works, and empower them with the agency and support to live in the ways that work for them - not how they are told they 'should' be.
Through my years of this work, I have heard one thing consistently about people who have received ADHD and autism diagnoses for themselves or others:
It helped me to be kinder to myself.
The power of this cannot be overestimated. Realising that maybe everything is not your fault, and you're not just 'weak' or 'lazy' or 'stupid', but you are a human being who has always done their best within broken systems, is like receiving a permission slip to be yourself.
And that might be precisely the problem that the 'experts' have with this. Because if people are seeking the diagnosis, but not 'treatment' through medication, what does that mean for them? What does it mean for an industry that is built on diagnosing the non-compliers, if everybody refuses to comply?
If shame and stigma is not reserved for the one with the label of a 'disorder' or 'deficit', but for the systems that fine parents if their children refuse to go to school, what does this mean for a capitalist society?
My dad called me after watching this documentary, saying that no show had ever made him so furious. He mentioned how there was absolutely no discussion of the fear at the heart of this: of parent's worried about their children taking their own lives. The suicide risk for people with ADHD is 3-6 times higher than for those without.
I can only imagine how heartbreaking it is to be a parent of a child who you know is inherently more vulnerable to exploitation and challenges than their peers. How you have tried everything you can, and would give anything for your children, but they are still existing in a world where the 'experts' are more concerned about philosophising and moralising rather than actually helping your child.
As I said to my dad, this emotion is energy in motion. It is a useful prompt for us to do something differently. To trust ourselves, instead of looking to external 'experts' for the answer. To take responsibility for understanding ourselves and creating an environment that works for us, even if others don't quite understand it.
A diagnosis is not a sentence, an excuse or an instruction to comply. It is a starting point - and, for many people, the first time their experiences have been taken seriously enough to be believed.
So please remember that behind arguments about labels, outrage-grabbing headlines and arguments with strangers on the internet are people trying to survive lives that they have been taught they are failing at. Reminding them that they are not alone is a powerful place to start healing a sick society.