When I read Oxford Professor Ludovic Phalippou's viral 6 page letter written to the students who did not attend his lectures in person, I was reminded of running an ADHD retreat.
Attempting to facilitate 12 people with ADHD being simultaneously engaged and in the same place, at the same time, multiple days in a row was like attempting to herd sheep whilst blindfolded. It wasn't that they didn't care - they'd all paid thousands of pounds to be there.
It was that someone would be running late, someone else would go to check on them, and fifteen minutes later I'd find them both in a completely unrelated conversation whilst everybody else had wandered off in their own directions. Getting everybody back into the same place was a challenge, but keeping them there was almost impossible.
One person would check their phone for the time and disappear into a vortex. Another would strike up a conversation with their neighbour and somehow recruit people from the other side of the room into it. I would often finish explaining an exercise before being asked to explain it again by people who wanted to participate, but had somehow missed the entire thing, as others would let me know that they didn't want to do it at all.
Running ADHD Works meant accepting long ago that people are ultimately beyond my control, but this was definitely the biggest test of my patience. There is no 'mute' button in real life, and it's really awkward to sit at the start time with the only other person who's turned up. The reality is that accessibility, inclusion, and fairness are often pulling in different directions - especially in groups of people who have conflicting needs.
A similar approach has been taken by the yoga studio I attend, where signs have popped up with reminders that anybody turning up late will be locked outside. Not one, but two yoga teachers have now explicitly referenced their disagreement with these 'rules' to the bewildered class.
We are seeing a similar situation right now, as the world attempts to force people back into 'real world' participation. The challenge is that it is much harder to demand conformity after a global pandemic where what our society collectively considered to be 'normal' changed overnight.
Before the pandemic, it was assumed that a person would have to travel to an office or classroom to participate, engage, collaborate, and contribute. Visibility became a shortcut for value, because measuring genuine engagement is difficult. The irony is that this incentivises presence and appearances, rather than the things we actually care about.
The world has changed faster than our institutions can keep up. Information is no longer scarce, and neither is access to experts. We can listen to them on podcasts, watch their talks on YouTube, and ask ChatGPT to explain their ideas in real time. The challenge is no longer obtaining information, but knowing what to do with it.
The students whom Professor Phalippou refers to are likely optimising their energy in a world of endless expectations - where we're all expected to do more and more, with less and less. As he notes, even those who did attend may not have been fully present. Caring about something and being able to engage with it are not always the same thing.
This was my experience of university. I'd arrive at lectures with the very best of intentions, armed with handwritten notes, coloured pens, and a fresh determination that this time I would pay attention.
Two hours later, I'd leave feeling considerably less intelligent than when I'd walked in. Despite my best efforts, every single time felt like the lecturer had spoken in a foreign language, and I could recall nothing at all. I'd repeatedly find myself on tangents after googling what a word meant and losing large chunks of the discussion. I was physically present, but mentally absent. Eventually, I gave up going at all.
I taught myself what I needed to know to pass the exam with the help of Wikipedia, and graduated with absolutely no idea of how I'd achieved a 2:1 in law, let alone how to use it in the 'real world'. I had long missed the vacation scheme and training contract application deadlines my fellow students had spent months preparing for, before entering 7 rounds of assessments like they were the literal hunger games.
I felt hopeless about the future, and spiralled into a significant mental health crisis, resulting in an ADHD diagnosis a few years later that I initially completely disagreed with. Ironically, learning more about neurodivergence explained the challenges I'd previously been unable to understand, as well as what I actually need in order to engage.
For me, that means sitting at the front of the class, with all electronics out of reach. It's not exactly revolutionary advice, but it works - and it wasn't something I would ever have chosen as a student who spent most of university trying not to draw attention to herself.
A decade later, I'd guess that most students today are experiencing similar challenges. The screens we all look into for most of our waking hours have been designed to hack our executive functioning capabilities, keeping us scrolling whilst blaming ourselves for our 'laziness'.
Our society doesn't incentivise participation - it incentivises results. Certificates that can be shared on social media. Stamps that can be added to a CV. Qualifications that can be displayed on LinkedIn. Attendance that can be measured. Hours that can be logged. Salaries that can be compared. Followers that can be counted. Productivity - or engagement itself - that can be tracked.
And humans are wired to choose the path of least resistance - using the least energy possible. So why would a person choose to spend their time focused on learning, when they could instead be collecting more and more of these external stamps of approval? Why would they memorise another language if their phone could translate it in real time? Or travel several hours to attend a lecture when they could listen to it whilst going for a run?
The only answer I have is that they have to want to do it - which is not something that we can control, force, or be responsible for, because we are not them.
Halfway through every ADHD coaching course, I ask exactly the same questions. Is everyone okay? Has anyone suddenly decided they've wasted their money? That they can't do this? That everyone else is doing better than them? Every time, somebody asks how I got inside their head.
The answer is experience, and knowing that this isn't about me, or the course, or them - but that once the initial novelty and excitement wears off of anything we try to do in life, fear kicks in. When we get to the halfway point, we start finding all of the reasons why we can't do this at all.
The irony is that it's often far scarier to pursue something we want than to convince ourselves we never wanted it in the first place. We are often not scared of failure as much as we are of success.
And I generally always remind them that there is no such thing as 'success' or 'failure' - because everybody is on a different path. I remind them that although this course might say its 6 weeks long, they have got the REST OF THEIR LIVES to do all of the lessons. That they will be able to pass the assessment, because I am not here trying to catch them out.
I don't see passing an assessment as the point of these courses, because I knew how to pass assessments without actually participating. For me personally, I see it as people who take what they need to take from it, and being a little kinder to themselves. We live in a world where it's far more 'productive' to pay for a course to be certified as able to offer a service or skill, than it is to pay for that service for ourselves.
And so my courses are somewhat of a Trojan horse: an attempt to create the kind of learning environment where I would have felt safe enough to turn up, participate fully, have fun, and leave feeling that what I'd learned was actually relevant to, and useful within the world outside of the classroom.
But when I hear people tell me how this course enabled them to do the thing they love, but had avoided for 2 years (rock climbing), or to feel safe enough to turn up to a space even though they don't feel their best, or how it's helped them to have a great conversation with their child they wouldn't have otherwise have had, that feels like success to me.
A packed room can be just as disengaged as an empty one. It's only by creating environments where people feel safe enough to be vulnerable that learning becomes something we participate in, rather than simply consume.
Because the one thing I know for sure is that the thing that often stops us from showing up, participating, and engaging isn't the fear that the content isn't good enough. It's the fear that we aren't, in a world of increasingly impossible expectations on us all.
Become an ADHD Coach in July here