PSA: Neurodivergence is not an excuse to abuse people or commit crimes

This week, I updated the 'purpose' of ADHD Works:

Helping people take personal responsibility within broken systems, and empower themselves to live a life that works for them.

Our values are:

  • Trust: we hold space for messy vulnerability, allowing people to be who they need to be.
  • Belonging: everyone belongs - neurodivergent or neurotypical. No one should feel alone in the world.
  • Integrity: we always do what’s right, even when it’s difficult.
  • Authenticity: we value people as their unique selves - not copies of each other.
  • Compassion: we lead with kindness - ensuring we fill our own cup first.
  • Accountability: perfection doesn’t exist - but taking ownership of our actions, being transparent, and embracing mistakes is vital for ourselves and others.

Understanding ADHD and autism has helped me to forgive myself and others, even if they are never going to share this view. I can see how their actions weren't a choice, but a result of doing the best they could with what they had available to them at the time.

This is for my benefit - not theirs. Forgiveness doesn't equate to excusing someone. We can only do our best with the knowledge available to us at the time, including the present. People can choose to learn and take responsibility for themselves at any point.

However, having experienced a lot of trauma throughout my life, I don't want to spend the rest of it stuck in the past, trying to find an answer for what's happened to me, or blaming others. This knowledge allows me to take responsibility: setting boundaries today with those who are unable to meet me on the same level of understanding about this.

My work as an ADHD coach helps others who are ready for this level of self-reflection and accountability to take control of their life. It's not about blaming other people or our neurodivergence: it's about recognising it, and acting accordingly.

So, it makes me furious to see people who use neurodivergence as an excuse. It can explain, but not excuse. Unfortunately, this can be exploited by people who see an opportunity to justify their actions with any excuse they can find.

This is not only bad on a personal level, but also a wider societal level. It adds to the stigma of 'over-diagnosis', 'victim mentality' and 'a bandwagon'. The majority of people who have been diagnosed with a condition like ADHD or autism, especially of their own accord later in life, are not doing so for fun. Asking for help requires a level of humility in recognising that we need it at all.

That turning point, which has often been called a 'rebirth', is not about finding a lifelong excuse to avoid accountability. It's about recognising that we've been trying our best within a system that's not designed for our brain. I've never met a person who hasn't experienced trauma of some kind - but most of them do not go on to abuse other people.

Understanding this means we have less of an excuse, because now we understand this.

Knowledge is power, but that power can be misused. This is especially so by people in positions of authority, like James Bubb.

Surprisingly, the headline of this article wasn't 'rapist blames it all on ADHD'. I'm not sure if that's a good thing, given the inevitable stigma that would arise in assuming everyone with ADHD does things like this, and the broader narrative against ADHD in our society.

The fact that this person became a volunteer policeman with the Metropolitan Police, boasting about his 'powers', alongside raping and groom multiple children is evidence that the ADHD they were diagnosed with as a teenager had nothing to do with it.

I have personally met two other volunteer police officers with the Met who have done similar actions in grooming and abusing children. The person who did it to me did not know about this convenient excuse at the time, but they were also never held accountable - because I was a child.

The other justified their actions by brandishing their 2 ADHD diagnoses received after being found out, suggesting this meant that they were in fact the victim. He is now in prison. This is somewhat similar to James, who was diagnosed with ADHD as a teenager.

We don't get to pick and choose how our neurodivergence works - we have to take responsibility for ourselves as a whole. Those who know better, should do better.

9 out of 10 autistic women have been genuine victims of sexual violence. This doesn't mean that they have an excuse to harm others. It means that they are more likely to be abused.

1 in 4 prisoners have ADHD. This doesn't mean that they should all be excused of their crimes.

When I worked in mental health and disability legal policy, there was a common question about culpability and mental capacity. This is fundamentally down to a broken system.

I've met someone who spoke about killing people with a chain-saw like it was choosing what to eat for lunch, to a broken woman who'd drowned her children because she genuinely believed their lives were under threat during a psychotic episode.

Another had killed their neighbour by setting a fire to warn them about constantly playing music that existed only in their heads. That person had previously been in hospital, and concerned people in their life had raised the alarm to the NHS on multiple occasions about their deteriorating state, who did nothing.

Where does the responsibility lie in these situations? I don't think people are born 'bad' - I think a broken system contributes to their decline.

There is a big difference between those who internalise and externalise this. Those who feel suicidal, like the 1 in 4 women with ADHD who attempt to take their own life, and those who kill others, like the person who open fired on children whilst they prayed at school this week.

There's also a significant difference in what vulnerability does to a person. It took me a long time to stop blaming myself for the things that happened to me as a child, because I was a child who should have been protected.

The law has to apply linear cut-off points, like the age of consent, but this doesn't necessarily reflect reality. For example, a 30% delay in executive skills means that children with ADHD are not developing the skills of self-regulation at the same level as their peers.

Neurodivergence is not mental illness, because it can't be 'cured' - and it doesn't need to be. It's simply part of who a person is. Unfortunately, the law doesn't currently prevent people from being sectioned for this anyway - 67% of mental health hospital inpatients are autistic.

However, growing up in a 'one size fits all' world without access to support or understanding of why we find things so difficult, inevitably results in mental health challenges. We blame ourselves, unable to understand why things that seem so 'easy' for everyone else feels impossible for us. This does not mean that we go on to commit crimes or abuse people.

It certainly doesn't mean that we deliberately seek out positions of power, like becoming a volunteer police officer, to shield our actions. But ask yourself: why do our police force recruit volunteers in the first place? Between 2010 and 2016, 60% of police staff and 40% of Police Community Support Officers were cut.

Why would they pay people to do this job if others would do it for free - and why would those people choose to do so?

We may live in a broken system, but each and every one of us has personal responsibility not to contribute to that. After my local police station was inexplicably closed (despite being in an area rated 7/10 for crime - high), and I can barely go outside without a balaclava wearing man zooming past me on an electric bike, having grabbed people's phones, I felt helpless - and afraid.

Then I realised that I am not powerless. Firstly, I wrote to my property management company to ask them to review security. Then I found the local SEND organisation and offered help. Then, I wrote to my MP to offer support in creating community initiatives, understanding the link between unsupported neurodivergence and crime.

This doesn't excuse the people terrorising my local area, or the council in deciding to simply remove police officers. It's not me seeking out a position of authority to give me 'powers' I can use to harm others. It's simply volunteering my skills to a much wider problem that might be able to impact it - and I felt a lot better for it.

We all make mistakes, but we also all have the ability to recognise this, so that we don't perpetuate further harm. We all live in broken systems, but we are not broken - or helpless. Taking personal responsibility is empowering, because it reminds us that we have agency - regardless of trauma, mental health, neurodivergence, or anything else.

Personal agency is the kind of power that you can't be accredited in by an external organisation. It's fundamental to being human, underlying our autonomy and free will. It's what builds trust in ourselves, and the world - even if it can be a scary place to be.

It also grows with every experience we have. Every experience of exploitation and abuse has given me knowledge of how to protect myself better in future. Of course, I would have much preferred them not to have happened at all, and they have caused me significant harm to the point of feeling suicidal for many years.

But the big difference today is that I do not feel suicidal, because I know that the rest of my life isn't dictated by these events. They are not inevitable. I have knowledge today that I didn't know then. My autism diagnosis was a huge part of this, in recognising how my inherent vulnerabilities were exploited by others who could see them when I didn't know they existed in the first place.

In an increasingly divided world where mental health problems are spiralling, recognising our ability to take accountability and change our lives has never been more important. Messy, imperfect conversations, where we can recognise a contribution of factors to a situation, are needed - urgently. This is what ADHD Works is about.

Become an ADHD Coach in September here

Want support that works with your brain?

Answer 6 questions to be matched with an ADHD Works trained coach, or train to become one yourself.

Find your match Become a coach
Previous
Previous

Lived experience matters - but who decides how valuable it is?

Next
Next

Transparency in ADHD Coach Training - ADHD Foundation Insolvency