Lived experience matters - but who decides how valuable it is?

On the first week of my new job in mental health and disability law, I was asked to give a 5 minute speech.

Inexplicably, I said, 'I went on Lorraine this morning, but two years ago today, I wanted to end my life' - before bursting into tears.

This came from publishing a book about the modelling industry, which I'd intended to finish before ending my life. Ironically, writing that book meant I had to surrender to accepting that I had ADHD. The medication saw my suicidal thoughts disappear overnight, and I managed to get a 'real' job.

I never wanted to think about modelling again, but instead, found myself on the cover of the Times and being asked if I'd ever felt suicidal by a researcher for Lorraine. If I had 15 minutes of fame, I thought I had a duty to help others, seeing as I was still alive - but I really wasn't ready to share this.

Ironically, it didn't even come up in our interview, but it had still brought up a lot of trauma that exploded into the new life I was trying to build.

A couple of years later, despite severe imposter syndrome, I impulsively published ADHD: an A to Z in response to my GP's 7 year waiting list and a lack of relevant information. I believed I'd ruined my life by stamping ADHD on my forehead, but was amazed at how many people messaged me about how sharing my 'lived experience' had helped them.

Today, there's a lot of noise about 'lived experience' and who 'should' be listened to, especially around neurodiversity. Here's my thoughts:

1. Why do they care so much?

After The Walt Disney Company contracted me to train 250 mental health first aiders as ADHD Champions, I received my first 'hate' post from a stranger - who happened to be a neurodiversity trainer. 🙃

We can't avoid the obvious in people complaining about others joining their 'market', whilst being in that exact market. This is even more ironic if they're aiming to increase diversity, inclusion, and accessibility.

Many factors are out of our control, including who chooses to work with or listen to us, and social media algorithms. This doesn't reflect our value, but the need to adapt to a rapidly changing environment.

2. Are people with 'lived experience' being exploited?

Within the 'lived experience' educator (or 'influencer') world, I see many similarities to exploitation within the modelling industry:

  • Vulnerable people being sold a 'dream' - with expectations that are rarely met
  • Exploitative and complicated contracts that restrict their agency
  • Assumptions that they should be 'grateful', including working by for free
  • No set working hours or pay rates, with constant fear of being unable to pay the bills
  • Extreme highs, followed by inevitable extreme lows, feeling like we've 'hit our peak'
  • A lack of regulation, protections or safeguarding
  • The commodification of human beings for who they are, not what they do - leading us to edit ourselves to fit 'demand'

When you are the product, your identity is up for sale. 57% of Gen Z want to be 'influencers' when they grow up, but they're literally growing up being influenced to be influencers. Yes, they might be sharing stories for engagement on social media - but for what purpose?

It's hard to know what the reality of selling your soul involves, until you've learned the hard way - through lived experience.

3. Is everyone else being exploited?

Yes - but by algorithms that reward division and controversy, including on 'professional' platforms like LinkedIn. Outrage is contagious, because it invokes fear - shutting down genuine conversation and connection.

This often happens with the intention of 'helping' or 'educating'. Telling someone off for expressing themselves is likely to cause invalidation, shame, and fear - not true understanding and growth. Why leave a public passive-aggressive comment, when you could drop someone a direct message?

It's ironic to see this in the neurodivergent community, where small differences in thought, even down to a single letter or word, are magnified and criticised. The core of inclusion means accepting people who are different to us, even if we disagree - it's creating a space where everybody is inherently good enough to 'belong', exactly as they are.

4. Who's voice is valid - and who decides?

The professional world has commodified and controlled lived experience, often based on outdated research.

For example, ADHD couldn't be diagnosed in UK adults until 2008. ADHD and autism couldn't be diagnosed in the same person until 2013. Professionals are trained on outdated diagnostic criteria, which is based on the experiences of white, male, middle-class children.

The tension between 'professional vs lived experience' reflects the fear that systemic change may cause in those who have always benefitted from the status quo.

Who's experiences are more 'valid' than others? Which experiences in training provide credibility - and how is that decided? What counts as training, especially within standardised educational systems? Why do people listen to one person, but not another? Who gets the right to speak on behalf of others - and why?

To change broken systems, we need to feel safe enough to recognise that nobody is perfect. People's needs inherently clash, but progress depends on navigating these realities through compromise. For this, we need the skills to hold these complexities, have awkward conversations, and change what's not working.

5. Which information is valid - and who does it impact?

One of my main concerns in starting ADHD Works was raising awareness without the systems in place - either by employers or society - to back it up.

Knowing you have rights doesn't mean much if using them is impossible. With a background in disability law, I could see the risks, which is what led me to write ADHD Works at Work.

Once you've disclosed a disability at work, you can't take it back. If there are no policies in place, it's hard to trust that you will be supported, or even believed.

For example, in this podcast episode, it's asked whether 'traditional disabilities, like being a wheelchair user having some kind of sensory, you know, disability like being deaf or not having brilliant eyesight or whatever are being kind of crowded out by neurodiversity?'

Under the Equality Act, disability is disability - employers can't pick and choose. As in 1 in 4 people are disabled, and 70-80% are 'non-apparent', it's highly likely they already have disabled employees - they just don't know it. Understandably, these people may fear judgement or being disbelieved if they ask for help - and the consequences are unpredictable.

We train ADHD coaches to handle these situations carefully, because conversations about the workplace are inevitable. Well intentioned professionals in this area need to be aware of the potential implications of their words, and how to signpost safely to protect both themselves and others.

6. What impact does mental health have?

No one is immune to trauma, stress, or mental health challenges, and there's no one size fits all - everyone reacts differently. This doesn’t make their abilities any less valid, it does mean that our 'window of capacity' and tolerance levels can fluctuate.

I take safeguarding extremely seriously in my work with vulnerable people, both in training and coaching. Challenges can and do surface at any moment. The key is being able to recognise them, and address each situation as it arises with integrity and care.

My background in mental capacity law has shaped this approach. The law looks at whether someone can understand and retain relevant information, weigh the pros and cons, and communicate their decision. For me, capacity is best reflected through self-reflection and personal responsibility - including for myself, just as much as others.

Needing help isn’t a weakness, but a strength. Mental health isn’t linear, and none of us are ever fully 'healed.' What we can do is learn to understand, trust, and accept ourselves more deeply, and in doing so, support others to do the same.

I try to share 'scars, not wounds', with clear boundaries around what I make public. Each of us can only take responsibility for ourselves, and trust others to do the same.

Struggling is part of being human. By being honest about this, we free not only ourselves, but everybody else from holding themselves to impossible standards. Every time someone shares their experiences, it gives someone else the courage to keep going - even if they don't 'like and subscribe'.

This is how change is happening, because sharing our own lived experience isn't a weakness or individual failing - it's changing the system.

Become an ADHD Coach in September here

Want support that works with your brain?

Answer 6 questions to be matched with an ADHD Works trained coach, or train to become one yourself.

Find your match Become a coach
Previous
Previous

AuDHD: Burnout, Dopamine & Screens

Next
Next

PSA: Neurodivergence is not an excuse to abuse people or commit crimes