Trigger warning: this newsletter talks about subjects that may prompt strong emotional reactions, including sexual violence.
Earlier this year, I met a very successful man who said something to me that I expect many will resonate with. He was very upset about a bumper sticker he'd seen on a car saying 'believe all women', because he was a white man - which was apparently the worst thing you could be in such a world.
I have seen similar visceral reactions from men all year. An extreme fear of women, all of whom they suspect to be after their money and trying to entrap them with babies or false accusations. Extreme anxiety about the '#metoo movement' as men like Russell Brand are sentenced to 10 years in prison for behaviour that has been normalised and sold to them over their lifetimes.
This behaviour has also been entrenched by systems and those who operate within them, including women. When I reported sexual assault to a spa this year, the woman I spoke to assured me that the man responsible was 'such a nice guy' and had 'such great reviews'. I said I knew that, but he'd also explicitly told me that he knew what he was doing was not allowed, and when I'd asked why, he'd said he didn't know. It was just normal for him - part of the job.
He apologised profusely as I cried, andyet somehow I felt bad. Just like every other woman I know, I have experienced so much sexual assault that I have also normalised it to the point of being able to convince myself that it's somehow my fault, but his confession removed that coping strategy.
In reporting it to the police, I was repeatedly told how awful the trial process is for victims, and asked if I was happy to proceed (which I took literally - no I wasn't 'happy', but I would if needed). However, I eventually saw enough that I decided to drop it, because this is a broken system - not simply an individual.
It might seem odd to share this on LinkedIn of all places, but this happened within a workplace, just as much of the behaviour associated with Russell Brand happened within workplaces, often literally broadcast to the public.
He was extremely open about it because he and the systems around him profited from his 'brand'. And what is modelled in the public arena, with celebrities and politicians, is mirrored in offices and amongst the public, in private. It becomes normal.
I can understand the perspectives of men who feel scared and angry about the #MeToo movement, especially as we now live in the global court of social media, where the sentence can be being 'cancelled'. Leaning into that unspoken fear, and the stigma around it, is how people like Andrew Tate have millions of followers, or even become President.
As the online world strips us of empathy for one another, people will take whatever outlet they can get. The shame surrounding the fears of men, especially those who are 'successful' (read: rich), that a woman will accuse them of something they may not even remember doing - or didn't realise they were doing - is likely to be overwhelming.
This is especially so as men are conditioned to detach from their emotions, and expected to 'man up'. Yet in reality, these men have just as much emotional depth as the women who've been conditioned to detach from their bodies, and 'shut up'.
When women were shut out of professional life and instead expected to provide unpaid domestic labour, those who refused to comply could be accused of witchcraft. Or they could be institutionalised by the men in their lives, for reasons such as 'hysteria'. Psychiatry has developed under this model: a way to manage those who aren't playing their expected role in society.
And so, as the value of women as a consumer and workforce market began to be recognised, so did the expectations on us all. That women should be perfect mothers, housewives, and #girlbosses - but men should still, of course, be the breadwinner.
I recently read Gisele Pelicot's autobiography, in which she describes how her then husband began drugging and raping her at a time when his career was faltering and hers was flourishing. During his trial, she also discovered that he had himself experienced severe sexual abuse as a child, which he had never disclosed to her.
This is not an excuse. But it does remind us that people can carry experiences that we know very little about, and that understanding someone's history is not the same as excusing their behaviour. When he was 17, Russell Brand's father, for example, took him abroad where he paid for a prostitute to take his virginity.
When I was writing the Model Manifesto book, I initially didn't cover the experiences of men at all, until a proof-reader pointed this out. Over coffee, the one male model I knew personally told me about how he'd been sexually assaulted on numerous jobs, which he'd never told anybody else about.
He was afraid of being accused of lying, or being homophobic, or it negatively impacting his career. There has been no equivalent #MeToo movement for many men and boys, including those growing up in the 'manosphere'.
There's a reason emotional dysregulation isn't itself in the diagnostic criteria for ADHD or autism, despite being a very common lived experience. I recently saw a little boy hit a little girl because he felt excluded from a game they'd been playing. His mum picked him up and carried him away screaming that he'd been excluded, and it wasn't his fault - or fair.
The little girl just stood with her friends, crying, before pulling her jumper over her face and walking around unable to see. Her response would be considered 'emotional', whereas his would be 'impulsive' - 'boys will be boys'. I was filled with anger and sadness for her, in being conditioned to believe that she just needs to be more inclusive in the future to avoid being physically assaulted or blamed for it. And for the boy, who wasn't taught to regulate his emotions or behaviour, but carried away.
And this correlates to the world we all live in today.
Last week, I wrote about how the increased recognition of ADHD in women over recent years correlates with claims of 'over-diagnosis' and bandwagons. This was shared by a man who felt it reduced medical failings to arguments about gender. Against my better judgement, I tried to argue back, pointing out how men have been failed and forgotten by this system just as much as women.
Just like I said to the man who was upset about the thought of all women being believed, including strangers he'd never met, ironically, this is not a gendered issue: it's a capitalist one. We are living in a bizarre society where money and fame are put on a pedestal above everything else, including the feelings of our fellow human beings.
We are almost so connected that we have lost the capacity to feel truly connected.
Humans traditionally bonded in groups of around 150 people - yet this newsletter will land in the inboxes of over 58,000 people. The way our hunter-gatherer ancestors bonded was through an 'us versus them' mentality, where strangers were dangerous. Today, we broadcast our entire lives to them, often out of loneliness, along with everybody else on the planet. To stand out, we have to resort to tactics such as provoking outrage or 'engagement', even if we don't really believe in what we're saying. The ends justify the means - or we've lost the capacity to consider the means from any other perspective in the first place.
Which is precisely why I try not to comment on such posts, just like when you're told to ignore bullies in school. They are indeed, doing it for attention - and they don't care about whether they're right or wrong. Every outraged comment is another to hit of dopamine, rewarding this kind of anti-empathetic, divisive behaviour, and normalising it for others.
But I am only human, as are they, and then a completely pointless argument began, because the substance of the post was never actually the point. This reminds me of talking on LBC radio this week about Kemi Badenoch's comment that people with ADHD apparently wouldn't find trains useful - it's all about the context.
And then this comment was posted by a man I do not know.
It hit something in me emotionally, which was quite helpful to ask myself: what the hell am I doing and to end it by blocking both men. But the comment stayed with me, because it represents so much of everything I've said here.
1) Us vs them - 'if you are a man'
Someone talking about an experience that is different to yours is not an attack on you. Your feelings are valid, but they might just be projected at the wrong person or group.
This can again be explained, but not excused - it's understandably overwhelming to feel complicit in something you didn't even realise was happening. This might threaten the foundations of everything you believe about yourself, and make you feel vulnerable.
And in a world where we're all used to numbing out our emotions by engaging in the equivalent of public stoning through social media and the news, this might suddenly feel terrifying.
Even if you have no idea how to regulate these emotions, they will still come out in one way or another, just like how domestic violence incidents rise after football matches. Having someone to blame can help us to feel momentarily in control, and women have been the scapegoat ever since Eve dared to not follow instructions, and commit the sin of eating an apple.
2) Irrationality - 'no matter how well argued your point'
Men, through no individual fault of their own, have grown up in a world where it's simply normal for women to be the unpaid domestic labourers, and where crying is 'weak'. Boys today are growing up being pelted with violent pornography from all angles, whilst seeing the public shaming happen against men like Russell Brand only after he's been convicted of the crimes he's very openly disclosed.
He has even used these experiences as explicit material for his work, which would have been marketed to these boys and girls alike, for the last 20 years. No wonder he feels victimised, just like Huw Edwards. Another celebrity has recently used the legal system to argue for an injunction preventing the publication of a 278 point sexual misconduct report, because of the risk that they might take their own life.
It was also revealed this week that, in 2015, Russell Brand and his then girlfriend, Jemima Goldsmith, obtained a permanent injunction against Szilvia Berki, a massage therapist who had accused Brand of assault in the course of her work.
The injunction prevented her from speaking about this to anyone, even to her friends or family. Apparently her accusations caused them 'anxiety and distress' - and they succeeded because she had no resources to obtain legal representation. She wasn't even granted the 'luxury' of a trial by jury - she was just silenced from the start.
I decided not to pursue a career as a solicitor after being threatened by a firm on a daily basis, pressuring me to sign a NDA for their client. As the victim, who also didn't even receive any compensation, I knew I had absolutely no need to sign. My legal background meant I was fully aware that no judge would ever enforce what was essentially a slave labour contract I'd been pressured into signing, but I also had no money to pay for a lawyer.
It was so awful that eventually, I signed it. That experience showed me that 'rationality' ultimately comes down to who has the most money, and the least empathy or compassion. And so yes, this situation is irrational - and no matter how well argued your point, there will be people who disagree with you. They just don't all have the same opportunity to use their voice, let alone be heard or listened to.
3) Labelling - 'a model first and law student second'
Yesterday, I had a fascinating conversation with Erika Diskancova for her brilliant podcast, 'Formerly Known As'. The label of 'model' was forced onto me as a child, and again as an adult who was groomed by strangers. I was convinced that the stigma attached to this label would mean I would never be taken seriously in the future.
And this is a reminder for all women, of how no matter how successful we might be, we will always be able to be reduced to our looks. As Kate O'Connell wrote:
'As with most things, at the root of it all is power. By reducing a woman’s worth down to her appearance, we slyly diminish her role and her value as a contributor to society. People care far too much about how things look, rather than looking at how things are.'
If women are primarily judged for their appearance, how do we judge the value of men? Why does the global appearance economy for women represent approx. 1.3% of global GDP, whereas the male market is around 0.25%?
In contrast, the global women's health market represents 0.05% of global GDP. Our society collectively spends nearly 26 times more more on maintaining or altering women's appearance than on women's medical health. And less than 5% of medical research funding is dedicated to conditions specific to women.
The answer is that men are not in the picture - they are the ones expected to earn the money for women to spend on maintaining the illusion of never getting older, who were traditionally viewed as their property in the eyes of the law.
So if women are now earning their own money within the industries that were previously reserved exclusively for men (women were barred from practising law until 1919)... what do they need men for? If a wife could legally be raped by her husband as recently of 1991, were husbands taught about what rape looked like in the many cases where women don't feel able to verbalise a no, or how to handle their own emotions about this?
4) Capitalism - 'if there's money to be made out of infirmity'
Sadly, capitalist markets are entirely built on infirmity - a state of weakness or vulnerability. The way we are sold to is by being convinced that we need to buy something, when very often, we do not.
When I was made to model maternity wear as a non-pregnant 21 year old, a relative expressed how angry they were about this - because women who are pregnant have to buy new clothes. It is far harder for them to stay in their careers, or to stay 'professional' (i.e unemotional) whilst incubating an entire human being in their body - or once it has been birthed.
I am a brilliant business-woman, as noted in the comment, because my body has been the tool used to trigger people's insecurities in order to get them to buy stuff. As a 13 year old, I was in Vogue as the 'face' (and body) of a womenswear campaign - which none of the women comparing themselves to my pre-pubescent body would know.
My 'secret', therefore, is that I can see through traditional sales tactics and choose not to engage in them myself. I do not sell to people by attempting to trigger any kind of insecurity or 'infirmity' - I simply share my own experiences, and make it possible for them to join me if they want to. But I make it very clear: absolutely nobody needs to.
And this, ironically, is why it works - because we're all sick of being sold a narrative that is literally unachievable. In a system that blames you for simply not trying hard enough, and keeps you running on a never-ending hamster wheel, acting outside of the status quo seems to work pretty well.
5) Femininity - 'no narrative as seductive as that of unfairness'
Another interesting choice of word: seductive. It reminds me of the dangers of seductiveness from Eve tempting Adam to share her apple, to the mermaids who lured sailors to their deaths by using their voices - singing to them.
From Pandora, the beautiful woman sent to earth to punish humanity for curiosity, Medusa, paralysing people with her gaze, and Helen of Troy, the seductive prize to be fought over and won.
Seductiveness here is weaponising desire within the defenceless victim, who is punished for succumbing to temptation. This of course, may feel inherently unfair, given that we are human beings and might have hoped for more for our life than days spent arguing with strangers on the internet.
This narrative provides us with an instant villain who we can onto whom we can project our pain at the unfairness of life. It relieves us of personal responsibility, offers moral superiority, and fuels the emotional feeling of grievance - bonding people together with purpose in a world where we're all feeling alone and purposeless.
It reminds me of the little boy who hit the girl, who shouted that it wasn't fair. He felt that it was justified because he was excluded, and now he's being punished for it - with further exclusion. And this is pretty much the world we are living in right now, all of us.
I don't know where we as a society go from here, but I think the answer is to connect with people in real life. To find a community, even if it feels painful and awkward and as though you don't belong there. This is the only way we will prove our beliefs wrong: in seeing that no, people are not out to get us.
We don't have to like everybody in this community, but we do need to recognise that we are bonded together in a way that means we don't all have to share the same exact views and beliefs. We have to rediscover how it is to trust another human being - that they will not hurt us, or if they do, they will be able to take responsibility for this so that they don't do it again. That fundamentally, they will care about us, and we will care about them.
They will not be perfect, and they will definitely not be as available as AI - but they will care that it's your birthday. They will notice if you don't turn up to work, and they will be able to look after you when you are sick - and vice versa. Our unique selling point is our common humanity - we have the ability to care.
For me, it helps me to have compassion for people and to understand that we are products of our environment. That it is not necessary to get revenge, or for there to be a 'winner' or a 'loser'. That things just are as they are, and we have the ability to make some choices in the limited time we are here on earth that can make it more or less enjoyable.
We can believe an explanation, without this needing to be an excuse. We can choose to see the common humanity in all of us, even if we all think differently. We are all doing the best we can with what we have available to us - but that doesn't mean that we can't do better.