Why it might feel like everybody got the manual to life... except you. πŸ‘‹

I recently read something that explained my lifelong difficulty in understanding others, and being understood:

One way to understand the difference between neurotypical and autistic communication is to view neurotypical communication as following an established path, while autistic communication is more like blazing your own trail. - Elora Dodd & C.R.R Hillin, The Actually Autistic Guide

It's like everyone is walking through the same forest. Most people follow an established path without even thinking about it, whereas some hack through the trees with a machete to reach their destination. It's not because they're lazy or impatient - they just can't see the path (literally or metaphorically).

Neurotypical communication relies on effortless implicit interpretations of layered subtext and context, almost like poetry. Autistic brains do not experience this same level of ease - we have to constantly and explicitly translate the poetry to understand the meaning behind it. This processing difference has been referred to as Context Blindness.

One style isn't necessarily better than the other - they are just different autopilot modes of 'normal'. This can be difficult to grasp if you are in the majority, following the path and collectively confused about the person indiscriminately hacking down trees with a machete, fighting through the weeds. It can be tempting to label their inexplicable behaviour - or them - as 'disordered'.

After all, it might be obvious to you what to do: just follow the crowd! But when that person tries, they have to use unimaginably extreme mental energy. They're having to simultaneously watch multiple people, decipher any patterns and anomalies, work out where they're stepping, and pretend that they can also see the path. Oh - and figure out how to make eye contact, so they don't appear 'rude' and end up in an argument.

So yes, they can follow the crowd - but it is extremely energy consuming to do so. In contrast, it's virtually impossible for the crowd to follow that individual - because they're operating on innate, creative instinct. They don't know where they're going, but they know how they'll get there as it happens. It's not personal: it's just different.

For example, two people who speak different languages are accepted to have a more difficult time understanding each other than others, but this is less obvious, and therefore less acceptable, when they are speaking the same language. This is nobody's fault - it's simply that unlearning what is 'normal' for us is extremely difficult.

This is referred to as the Double Empathy problem, and it's crucial to recognise that neurotypical people naturally assume subtext. They can't choose to switch off the navigator in their mind that hears what an autistic person might mean as a complete sentence as the start of one.

And so, they go looking for the rest of it, involuntarily interpreting meaning that wasn't necessarily there. In a world where 'most' people operate at surface level to interpret deeper subtext, to say what you mean can lead to some serious misunderstandings.

'If you say what you mean from the beginning, that can confuse them.'

Here's some examples of how this might look in practice:

1. 'Does this dress make me look fat?'

Path: 'It's not a flattering dress' -> destination is an interpretation of 'yes' in a way that blames the dress, not the person.

Machete: 'Yes' -> non-existent destination could be interpreted as, 'and you're ugly'.

2. 'I'm fine.'

Path: 'You don't seem fine - are you sure? Was it X?' -> destination assumes that the person is lying about being fine and will eventually share when ready to.

Machete: 'okay' -> a non-existent destination could be interpreted as, 'I don't care'.

3. 'We should go for coffee!'

Path: 'Would love to!' -> assumes the intent is an exchange of warmth, not an invitation.

Machete: 'Okay, are you free on Tuesday at 2?' -> a non-existent destination could be interpreted as, 'this person is really intense.'

4. 'How was your weekend?'

Path: 'it was good thanks, you?' -> assumes that the question was a ritual to acknowledge each other's existence outside of work.

Machete: 'fine' β†’ no reciprocal question could be incorrectly interpreted as 'I don't like you'

5. 'What are your goals?'

Path: 'I'd really like to take on more responsibility in the team' -> assumes the question isn't really about your goals, but implicitly demonstrating commitment to an established career pathway.

Machete: 'to stay employed for one year.' β†’ an honest answer, which was literally interpreted as inappropriate when I said it in a performance review. (It was replaced with 'teamwork', which I'd achieve by chairing a team meeting. 🫠)

As a result of being constantly misunderstood, and often punished for our differences, autistic people are conditioned to believe that their natural way of existing is wrong. And so, we try harder to be like everybody else. We take on the job of translating every interaction, the work of attempting to consider all infinite potential paths of what is being said or meant, and how to present ourselves in the least apparently offensive way.

For me, it feels obvious that we should all say what we mean, and mean what we say - but then again, I am autistic. The book gave a brilliant example of how this can be interpreted:

'To neurotypical people, when autistics communicate it's like they take their favourite sad song and replace the lyrics with, 'I am very sad and everything sucks'. They expected subtext, so bluntness would throw them off and ruin the fun.' - The Actually Autistic Guide

This is why understanding neurodivergence is so vitally important for individuals and the people in their life. This 'label' acts as a permission slip to simply believe someone's experiences, even if they differ to yours. It's confirmation that yes, this person cannot see the same path as 'most' people - and this isn't anybody's fault. It's not a personal failing, or a matter of effort. It's simply invisible.

Somewhat depressingly, understanding this is not like ticking a checkbox. It's the beginning of yet another pathway, one where if you're neurodivergent, you will realise that you've been experiencing the world through a bubble that nobody else realises is there. This also applies to the people on the outside, who might navigate uncomfortable feelings in not knowing how to help what they don't understand, and will never be able to genuinely experience themselves.

Temporarily, there's extreme relief in understanding why. In the longer term, there's something closer to grief in accepting that this is nobody's fault, because it means that there's no 'fix', and therefore no template of what to do next. There's only the continuous learning of how to believe each other and to meet in the middle, instead of demanding conformity.

So: if you can take anything from this, please believe that the people in your life are doing the best they can with what they have available to them.

Please believe that people do not want to cause trouble for 'the sake of it'. That the majority of us, regardless of neurotype, have good intentions. That any one of us could have a bad day, but it's so rarely about us - and so often about what is never said.

I wrote this to help me process some difficult experiences I've had recently, and I hope it has helped you too. The pain of knowing that you are the one who thinks differently to 'most' teaches you to automatically question your experiences and blame yourself for the way other people treat you - but please remember that this is not your fault.

If this resonates with you, please remember that you might have learned to cope in the world by assuming responsibility for interpreting everything and everyone around you - but this is not yours to hold. It's important to regularly remind yourself that most people are simply living according to a well-trodden path, and you are not a mind-reader. Neither are you a bad, rude, or evil person.

On the contrary, I'd guess that if you're still reading this, you're a conscientious, caring person, who tends to see the best in others, whilst assuming the worst in themselves. Instead of attempting to control the uncontrollable, start with trying to understand yourself as a person who is just as deserving of taking up space in this world as the people who are on the path.

None of this is solved by one side or person trying harder. But the more you can stay with yourself, instead of shaming yourself for the way your brain works, the less power it has when someone tells you that you've got it wrong. It starts with taking responsibility for ourselves and our experiences, instead of constantly searching for a path that we cannot see. Try to be kind to yourself along the way.

To join the waitlist for our next ADHD Coach Training, head here.

To read AuDHD: Blooming Differently, head here.


Want support that works with your brain?

Answer 6 questions to be matched with an ADHD Works trained coach, or train to become one yourself.

Find your match Become a coach
Next
Next

What is ADHD?