Since 13 years old, I have worked as a fashion model. My teenage years included modelling everything from wedding dresses to womenswear campaigns, featured in Vogue UK.
I hated all of it, not least because I felt like I was being used to make other women feel bad about themselves. It would be impossible for them to know that the dress doesn't look the same on them because they are not 14 years old.
If you're wondering why I did it, it's because the modelling industry literally exists by grooming vulnerable children.
Why?
Because capitalism is built off of our insecurities. We cannot buy back our youth, but we can hope that by buying this product, we might look like the model. Well, guess what: even the model doesn't look like the model.
The best thing that a model can be is a 'blank slate' for others to project their ideas onto, like a real life barbie doll. Although ironically, as time went on, I was continuously told at castings that designers were looking for a 'real woman', whilst often also being told I needed to 'tone up' (aka: lose weight) at the same time.
When I hit my 20s, I was issued with a fake pregnancy belly to strap on. Suddenly, I became the top selling maternity model for multiple brands - a fact that I was extremely ashamed of, especially as I assumed this was because I was 'big' at a size 8-10. It was definitely not what I wanted to do for 'work', but I felt trapped - being rejected from all 'real' jobs, despite having a law degree.
Worst of all was hearing from a pregnant person how furious they were to find out that the models they were buying clothes off of were not actually pregnant, as they made them feel so badly about themselves. Suicide is the leading cause of death for women between 6 weeks and 1 year after giving birth, and I was part of the problem.
Similar incidences of commercialising 'diversity' under the guise of 'inclusion' and 'representation' felt equally uncomfortable, and often openly tokenistic. (If you're interested, here's the evidence I submitted to Parliament about it).
And so, I felt just as conflicted in seeing the new release of the 'Barbie Fashionista Autism'.
The Chairman and CEO of Mattel is a man named Ynon Kreiz, chairing an approximately 45% female board. This shouldn't matter, but it does, because although this doll has been made in consultation with autistic charities and experts, the blueprint of female autistic representation towards children has ultimately been approved through the male lens of how this should look.
Well, it is a Barbie doll, after all. And just like all Barbies, and all women, there's no one size that fits all. (Fun fact: only 14% of major fashion brands are run by women).
However, I would genuinely love to hear how the consultation and decision making process actually looked in reality. Was the Autistic Self Advocacy Network paid for its work in partnering on this doll? Does the profit from the dolls being sold on the basis of a specific disability go back into the disabled community in any way - and what's more, should it?
For example, Mattel is presumably not responsible for providing public education about autism (or indeed the under-diagnosis of girls and women), but with respect, their purchase page could do better than:
- 'Barbie doll wears a lavender and white pinstriped dress with a relaxed, comfortable fit. The ruffle hem adds an extra pop of personality to her look!'
- 'As autism can impact fine motor skills, she wears her hair in a loose style accented by noise-canceling headphones. More than just an accessory, they help relax her when she’s sensitive to stimuli!'
- 'She comes with a fidget spinner that really works, too. From hanging with friends to having a picnic in the park or going to the movies, she loves having the spinner handy when she’s out and about!'
- 'Flexible joints at the elbows and wrists allow her hands to move freely so kids can play out stimming movements with the doll. She also wears flat, purple shoes for extra stability and style!'
- 'This Autistic Barbie doll comes with an Augmentative and Alternative Communication tablet -- a tool that helps her express herself in ways other than talking!'
- 'Kids 3 years and up can collect other Barbie Fashionistas dolls for even more fun with friends and fashion at playtime!'
If I knew nothing about autism, all I'd learn about it from this is that:
- Autism can impact fine motor skills, so wear your hair down
- Noise cancelling headphones be relaxing when sensitive to stimuli
- Autistic people love having fidget spinners handy when out and about
- Flexible joints at elbows and wrists enable stimming (does it?!?!?!?)
- The doll wears a loose, ruffled dress and flat shoes for extra personality, stability and style (unclear if this is specifically supposed to be linked to autism, but maybe that's just me taking it literally)
- An AAC tablet can help with expression in ways other than talking (which is nice - but there is no CONTEXT of why this would be relevant for autistic people)
This barbie is one many 'Fashionista Dolls... celebrating diversity and offering endless possibilities for storytelling and fashion exploration'. Labels include 'Doll With Type 1 Diabetes', 'Blind Barbie Doll', 'Doll With Down Syndrome', 'Doll With Natural Black Hair' and so on.
Interestingly, the 'curve' Barbies are pictured, but not explicitly labelled unless you click into the page description where it mentions that the doll, 'has a curvy body type'. What do the rest of them have, then?
The thought of kids being encouraged to 'collect 'em all!' like Pokemon cards makes me feel a bit depressed. Speaking of - where is the depression Barbie that featured within the Barbie Movie?
Ironically, this is by far the most realistic and representative depiction of a Barbie that I've seen:
'She wears sweatpants all day and night. She spent 7 hours today on Instagram looking at her estranged best friend's engagement photos while eating a family sized bag of starbursts. Anxiety, panic attacks, and OCD sold separately.'
How would the CPTSD, anxiety, dyslexic, schizophrenic, ADHDor OCD brands of Barbie look? What about if this autistic barbie were a Ken Doll? What would his 'comfortable style' look like?
As an undiagnosed autistic child, 'visible' signs that were missed did not include the headphones or AAC tools I never had in the first place. They did include me eating paper, (pica), chewing my hair and clothes non-stop (sensory regulation that's not so aesthetically pleasing), trying to hurt myself because I was so overwhelmed, and being chronically bullied or told off for reasons I didn't understand.
Oh, and lining up all of my Barbies in an assembly, pretty much every day. (As well as chewing them for additional sensory regulation occasionally. Gross.)
So: I remain conflicted about this autistic Barbie.
Ironically, I'd say that the Barbie below is probably the one I'd currently identify with most as my unmasked, onesie-wearing, pink-haired self. If I was a child faced with this new 'official' autism barbie, I might feel that this was somehow 'wrong' - and maybe that's exactly the point.
Making the invisible visible - or at least explicit - is often necessary in a neurotypical world filled with assumptions, but maybe each of these dolls should come with a warning label that THIS DOES NOT REPRESENT [ENTIRE CONDITION].
Or better yet, maybe we could move to a world where we don't need to categorise, label, and objectify human beings at all. Maybe we could help kids to validate themselves, instead of looking for external proof that they have a right to exist as they are.
This comes with education and conversations around what it means to be autistic for that individual. It requires thinking outside of the box - literally - not because there's anything 'wrong' with this particular representation of autism, but because there's so much more to every single one of us than what can be seen - or bought.