'We can't help you, because then we'd have to help everyone' - busting the 'ADHD Floodgates' myth 👋

This morning I went onto LBC Radio to explain why making support accessible (without having to wait for years or pay thousands for a diagnosis) does not 'open the floodgates'.

It was in response to the first report of the NHS ADHD Taskforce, which aligns strongly with our recommendations 2 years ago after running a petition calling for a public inquiry into ADHD support.

It's obvious: the current system is broken. Instead of gatekeeping support, just make it available to everyone. Instead of siloing it from a Governmental perspective, take a joined-up approach between departments like education, health, justice, and work.

Here's what I explained on the radio:

1. The law already applies to everybody, regardless of diagnosis

Yes, but this doesn't (and wouldn't) change anything from a legal perspective. Right now, the Equality Act 2010 applies to anyone regardless of formal medical diagnosis, because the test is legal. This is why Access to Work is available to anyone with a health condition, without requiring a formal diagnosis, for example.

However, many people are unaware of their rights under the Equality Act, or how to use them. Even if they are, organisations can simply refuse to meet their legal duty to make adjustments, as often seen with schools and universities.

In an educational context, there's very few routes of redress, in comparison to employment, where the tribunal can make unlimited awards for discrimination. This is why many parents have to get a diagnosis in order to be able to get support from the school, which is required to access an Education, Care, and Health Plan.

An ECHP is a legally binding document setting out support for an individual, such as funding to access a specialist school from the local council. Even then, this is not straightforward - there's been a 98.3% rate of parents and carers winning SEND tribunal appeals. This means that local authorities' decisions were upheld less than 2% of the time. However, to reach this point is expensive - and exhausting.

2. Help shouldn't be gate-kept - it can benefit *everyone*

The ADHD Taskforce justified their recommendations based on the £17 billion cost of 'untreated' ADHD to society. This is one point I would argue back against: we shouldn't need to justify providing support because of negatives like risk to mental health or prison.

This is reducing the issue down to a 'disorder', and ultimately, conformity. By focusing on a single 'condition', this also ironically perpetuates exclusion in our society. It doesn't address the 'cost' of 'conditions' like dyslexia, autism, dyspraxia, or Misophonia - or the benefits.

It talks about a 'whole person approach' between Government departments, but not when it comes to literal co-occurring conditions: where do the parenting or teacher 'training programmes' stop? Who falls outside of the gaps - is it those who don't fit into the traditional, outdated diagnostic criteria? Or those who fall 'close to the clinical threshold' - but how close?

Justifying help on this kind of basis can also create exclusion against people who are not neurodivergent, sparking conversations exactly like the one I had this morning. It simplifies the issue into an 'us vs them' approach. Why should one child get to stay inside at break time because they have an ADHD diagnosis, but another who is being bullied can't?

Help isn't a finite resource, and if helping one person means other people feel able to seek support - good! This will make the 'system' better for everybody.

3. Support is not a 'one-size-fits-all'

The radio presenter argued that it would be unfair to give everyone 'extra help', such as extra time in exams, because what about those who 'genuinely need it'? Firstly, in my experience, people who do not need that kind of help won't use it. Extra time in exams would have been pointless for me, as someone who usually finished early (and got straight A's).

They also wouldn't think to attempt to access it. I've spoken to several parents who were seeking coaching for their children, but when I spoke to them and they explained they didn't really want it, I said there was no point to go ahead. If someone doesn't want help, it's going to be pretty pointless.

Reasonable adjustments do not provide 'extra' help to 'boost' the disabled individual. Equality requires recognition of individual needs to level the playing field. When asking about adjustments to a law firm this week as a client, I was told that 'all clients are treated equally' - but that's exactly the problem.

I don't need 'equal' treatment - I need information provided to me in a way that my brain can understand it.

4. Help enables people to take personal responsibility

On the radio, I was consistently asked about 'pushy parents' and those seeking to 'game the system'. In response, I explained that support isn't about giving people a free pass to do what they want - it's helping them to understand their experiences through a new lens.

This helps to explain, but not excuse, poor behaviour. Education helps to empower people, especially to avoid exploitation. I explained how understanding what ADHD was saved my life - but I shouldn't have had to wait until age 25 to find this out.

Finding out about the 7 year waiting lists for an NHS assessment is what made me self-publish ADHD: an A to Z, because I thought something would be better than nothing. Naz Stevens describes how even just realising that you are not alone can be so life-changing:

5. A diagnosis is not necessarily the (only) 'answer' - but it's sold that way

I mean this literally. If people are on 7-10 year waiting lists to find out if they have a condition like ADHD, which they've probably researched heavily already, they are simply waiting to be told something they already know.

This means that they're waiting for years to start making changes that could help them now. In reality, the diagnosis can be very anti-climatic, as psychiatrists are not employed to take someone through the entire process of understanding what this means for them and what to do next. People can often feel 'diagnosed and dumped' as a result - unsure of what they are supposed to do next.

Julia Reedshaw explains below how helpful simply attending a free group coaching session can be - including for the loved ones of those who have been diagnosed. Neurodivergence doesn't just affect the individual - it affects everybody else in their life too, who are just as deserving of support tailored to their experiences.

6. A neuro-affirmative approach is possible - and it works

I explained how I have trained over 500 people as ADHD & AuDHD Coaches in the last few years. The majority of these people have been neurodivergent themselves, as am I. What I hear consistently is how these learning environments are the first kind that students have been able to genuinely engage with, reframing their previous experiences of education.

I'm not running around making constant adjustments for people - I simply listen and respond. If a change might help one person, I'll make it for everyone. I trust people - whether that's to keep their camera turned off in class, or catch up with the recording. I don't make them jump through bureaucratic hoops for no particular reason.

Sophie Hailwood summed it up perfectly:

I don't make them think they're the problem if they don't understand something - I talk about it. I don't shame people for asking questions, and have structures that enable flexibility and adaptability, whilst remaining coherent.

I'm also an employer, in running ADHD Works. Similarly, the secret to this is simply trusting people and enabling them to access support as needed - regardless of neurodivergence. We all work from home, on flexible hours. We offer interview questions to everyone in advance of interviews. We try our best to support every single person that seeks help from us.

As of right now, ADHD Works has fifty-two 5* reviews on Google - this approach clearly works. Help is not a finite resource, and it doesn't run out the more you give it. People can be trusted.

Join our free AuDHD Group coaching on 13 July here

Become an ADHD Coach in September here

Become an AuDHD Coach in November here


Want support that works with your brain?

Answer 6 questions to be matched with an ADHD Works trained coach, or train to become one yourself.

Find your match Become a coach
Previous
Previous

AuDHD: Hyper-Empathy, Vulnerability & Anger

Next
Next

The Invisible Shame of AuDHD