The Nice Girl Syndrome: Stop Abandoning Yourself (ESPECIALLY if you're neurodivergent)

A few years ago, I saw 'The Nice Girl Syndrome: Stop Being Manipulated and Abused - and Start Standing Up for Yourself' on a stranger's bookshelf and picked it up. It was a moment I will never forget - like someone had written a book for me.

At the time, I had no idea I was neurodivergent, but had spent my entire life feeling guilty for existing. I felt there was something deeply wrong with me, but I couldn't identify what it was - which mean I felt powerless to 'fix' it.

Being diagnosed with ADHD and autism has helped me to see how much my neurology has conditioned me into mistrusting myself and my instincts, time after time - always blaming myself for the way I have been treated by others.

Here's a questionnaire from the book: 'Are You A Nice Girl?' (and yes, men, this can indeed apply to you too.).

1. Do you have a difficult time asserting yourself with service people? (For example, sending a plate of food back, telling a salesperson you are not interested.)

A therapist once gave me the challenge of buying something with a large note, and saying 'no' when asked if I had any change. I remember how impossible it felt, the thought of taking up space, of inconveniencing a stranger who literally worked in a convenience store. It was their job to have the right change, not mine as the customer.

It took all of my effort to do this, and I realised that the person literally did not care at all, despite the endless internal debates in my head about it. Being neurodivergent adds to this: we can perceive ourselves through the perspectives of others as a default, ignoring what we want or need.

2. Do you get talked into things, including buying things, because you can’t say no?

'I felt bad', was my long-standing explanation for buying endless items I did not want or need. The person in the shop was so nice. I wanted to help them by giving their employer money. And now I have this reminder taking up space in my home for the rest of my life (or until I can bring myself to throw it away).

Combine this with the impulsivity and vulnerability of neurodivergence, and you have yourself a recipe for what is commonly called 'the ADHD tax'. Sure, we'll trust the nice app's free trial offer - before discovering that it takes a blood sacrifice and hours on the phone to the nice man to attempt to cancel. They even offered a discount!

3. Are you overly concerned about what people think of you?

The 30% developmental delay associated with executive functioning skills and ADHD includes that of self-awareness, which means that we may struggle with our own self-image and identity.

We might look for clues from other people, and if they think we're 'too much' or 'mean', we can feel immense shame. And so we prioritise their imaginary perceptions, over our own, constantly abandoning ourselves and berating ourselves for having such selfish thoughts.

4. Is it overly important to you that people like you?

As children with ADHD are said to receive 20,000 more negative comments than their peers by age 12, we may grow up assuming that everybody hates us as a default. This is linked to Rejection Sensitive Dysphoria: 'extreme emotional pain at real or perceived rejection'.

As a result, we can unconsciously dedicate every waking moment to figuring out who may currently be upset with us, and what we can do to change it. When we realise we've been masking our entire lives, building a whole identity just to be liked by others, we might realise that we don't even like the identity we've cobbled together of other people's projections.

Whether we like ourselves has possibly never even felt like a relevant option - until we realise we're living a lie.

5. Are you afraid to say how you really feel out of fear of making someone angry?

Yesterday, after an hour of intellectualising a situation with empathy and 'benefit of the doubt' to my therapist, I acknowledged that I was annoyed. The thought of saying this out loud to the person it was about felt impossible.

As I explained, whenever I try to do this I am misunderstood. It makes sense in my head, but it comes out all wrong. It is generally met with anger and me being cut off as a result of my inability to communicate the tornado of thoughts inside my head. I don't want to upset anyone - so I try my best to ignore or dismiss how I really feel.

That internalised anger at myself feels safer than anger from other people, which is unpredictable. People already seem to be angry at my very existence, so I don't want to add to their load.

6. Do you apologise too much, or too often?

My entire life is an apology. Often, I will say sorry for saying sorry so much. If someone bangs into me on the street, I will apologise.

This was helpfully conditioned from a career as a fashion model I was forced into doing from age 13. I was expected to do everything from have random strangers undress me to dancing as a monkey (literally) in front of panels of disapproving people. On one job, I received every insult imaginable - I was too tall, but also too short. My face was unsymmetrical. My eyebrows were uneven. My hair had split ends. My shoulders were lopsided. I was too fat, but also too thin. I looked too happy, but also too moody.

So, I learned very early on that the easiest way to survive was to get there first and apologise, even though these things were not within my control. If I reject myself first, it feels slightly easier to be on the side of the bully.

Maybe they will be less mean - but I will have new ammunition to add to lifelong my inner voice, dedicated to reminding me of how my very existence is wrong - and there's nothing I can do to change it.

7. Do you have friends or acquaintances you don’t really like or have much in common with but feel obligated to continue seeing?

I predict that if you're autistic or ADHD, that this one will hit a nerve. When I was diagnosed with both conditions, I realised that I didn't actually like very many people in my life. I realised that so many of my friendships were based on alcohol, and what I could do for them.

No wonder I was exhausted, or engineered our 'hang outs' to include tequila shots. I had always been 'picked', not even realising that I had a choice to pick who was in my life. When I told a 'best friend' I had been diagnosed as autistic, and she berated me for 'wanting a label', I finally stood up for myself and ended the friendship.

This is the 'permission slip' that helps you to draw a line in the sand, and see that actually, maybe it's not all your fault. Maybe there are other people out there who won't treat you like an emotional punching bag. Maybe you might even enjoy being around them - there's a world of possibilities ahead of you.

8. Do you often say yes to invitations because you don’t want the person to feel rejected?

Pre diagnosis, this very sentence could have summed up my entire social life. I was a very 'social' person, but I hated it all. I hated standing in line for clubs, freezing to death, and would promptly pass out as soon as we got inside to cope with the sensory overwhelm, fast asleep on the sofa.

I hated 'coffee catch ups', where it would have been really weird to have brought an agenda along. I hated parties, where I'd inevitably try to make sure everybody felt included. If no one invited me anywhere, I doubt I would ever leave my house at all - it is simply exhausting.

But when they do, my autistic interpretation of 'can you' do this equates this to 'yes'. My 'free time' is available to anybody to use - all they have to do is ask. If I can do it, I will - even if that means triple booking myself to be in 3 places at once, none of which I actually want to me.

My ADHD would engineer creative solutions to this, like combining meet-ups so that the 3 people could make friends with each other, and I could hide in the bathroom, before resenting them for preferring each other over me. Ironically, friendship feedback reports say that that this habit was particularly annoying.

9. Do you tend to give in because it makes you feel selfish if you refuse to help someone?

I once explained to a therapist how I would date literally anyone who wanted to date me. They misunderstood this as me saying I could date anyone. No - the opposite. I felt so terrible at the thought of rejecting literally anyone at all, that I was like a 24 hour helping ATM. Whatever you want, I've got it!

This is heightened by the hyper-empathy associated with autism, where we tend to be annoyingly perceptive of the people's feelings around us. RSD means we know the sting of rejection so well that we go out of our way to try and help others avoid feeling rejected, even if that means rejecting ourselves. We're used to it, after all. It's selfish not to be selfless.

10. Are you afraid people will dislike you if you’re not cooperative?

Of course. The number one label I was afraid of throughout my life was 'difficult'. If I didn't cooperate, I would be rejected - simple as.

11. Do you have trouble speaking up as soon as something or someone is unfair to you?

YES YES YES. A man I dated once physically assaulted me and I spent the next hour crying and ruminating about whether I could put ice on my arm or whether this would make him think I was accusing him of hurting me. Even though he literally did.

In a terrible way, upon reflection, that was actually one of the most helpful things he could have done. People I hardly even knew spotted the signs, and insisted on reminding me that it is not normal - or my fault. The bruising was a reminder that I could not ignore as easily as the endless manipulation and gaslighting that I could easily make my fault.

This is heightened when it comes to neurodivergence, especially as we've likely developed neural pathways to assume that we will be misunderstood and offensive if we dare to listen to our own intuition that maybe someone has been unfair to us. The strong sense of social justice compels us to be experts in advocating for everybody else, but never for ourselves.

12. Do you hesitate telling someone that he or she has hurt your feelings or made you angry because you don’t want him or her to feel bad?

Yes (see above). If they display the slightest sign of being upset at my distress, or usually clumsily and awkward apology about being mildly upset that they have oh, I don't know, literally lied to my face, I will immediately feel a sense of crushing guilt. I don't want them to feel bad. It must be my fault.

With neurodivergence, there comes a sense that you are overreacting - all of the time. That RSD doesn't make us snowflakes: it makes us highly resilient people who assume that we must take on responsibility for every bad thing that happens in the world, because it couldn't possibly be anyone else's fault. We assume the best in others, and worst in ourselves.

13. Do you avoid telling someone he or she has upset you because you don’t think it will do any good or will only cause a big problem between you?

Yes yes yes. When I was asked during my autism assessment about how I sought emotional support when I was hurt or upset as a child, I blanked. What was the point? Why would I tell someone my problems, only to burden them with mine as well (and then have to worry about them too?).

As an adult, this fear of telling anyone if I am upset with them (or more often, asking if they're upset with me), stems from a well-evidenced belief that they will simply cut me off. Almost every time I have attempted to do so, it has ended the relationship, even if temporarily.

So again, I ask you readers: what's the point? Then you only have to handle the awkward consequences of feeling even more frustrated when nothing changes. This is why it is often so difficult for neurodivergent people to ask for help: it comes with the very real risk that we will not receive it, and have to be 'upset' at the person as a result.

14. Do you have people in your life who take advantage of you?

Of course. What is life for, if not to serve other people and then stew in resentment at how much we've done for them, but they do absolutely nothing for us?

How are you supposed to just change this default setting, when your entire basis for relationships is transactional? When you feel grateful to any stranger for simply tolerating your existence, you don't even think of it as taking advantage: it's more like earning your keep.

15. Do you often take the blame for things just to avoid an argument or to avoid rejection or abandonment?

Always. It's easier to say it's our fault, and blame ourselves, than to hold out hope that someone else will fight to maintain a relationship with us. And let's face it, we can almost certainly find a long list of evidence that it was all of our fault, no matter the scenario.

And if it's a stranger? Even more so. Yesterday I was walking down the street at 6am when a jogger appeared behind me at the same time as I saw my bus pulling up ahead of me. I ran for it, and he crossed the road. I missed the bus anyway and slowed down (deeply unfit). I then processed the guilt for an hour of making this poor man think I was scared, even though I was. He didn't do anything wrong other than go out for a morning jog.

On behalf of all women who are similarly terrified by the very existence of men on quiet roads at 6am, I am sorry. It's not your fault I'm so arrogant as to believe that someone would want to attack me.

16. Do you often make excuses for people’s poor behaviour, telling yourself that they didn’t mean it or they didn’t know better?

Of course. The hyper-empathy associated with autism is frustratingly one-sided. This has worked as a strength: I have an amazing capacity to forgive anybody at all, just at the expense of any shred of self-respect or safety.

My general assumption is that everybody is doing the best they can with what they have available to them, and so I cannot be angry at anyone. When a previous ex-partner (who had already cheated on me) offered me a tea every morning, I would say I wanted a coffee. Every morning, I was given a tea. One day I erupted in anger, before apologising for being abusive and hauling him to couple's therapy to fix myself.

It was only there that he explained he literally did it on purpose because I was apparently 'aggressive' when I drank coffee. This was fortunate as I started working in the AuDHD world, seeing how often these diagnoses serve as helpful excuses, such as for grooming and abusing children.

Maybe their unconscious patterns are actually their responsibility to have done the work to become aware of, just as mine is. See exhibit A: Gregg Wallace. An ADHD or autism assessment isn't something you do after you've been caught to erase your past behaviour - you are responsible for this regardless.

17. Do you avoid conflict or confrontation at all costs?

Generally, although my avoidance tactics usually look like attempting to fix the problems myself. When I was cheated on, I dove into therapy to uncover exactly how it was my fault, reading endless books about infidelity and signing up to course after course.

It was only when someone said to me during a coach training session, 'you said we've tried everything. What have you tried?' that I realised WE had not tried anything. I had tried everything, whilst my ex gave me tea instead of coffee, continuing to chip away at my sanity. (And this, reader, is why I am so obsessed with coaching).

18. Do you get a terrible feeling when someone is angry with you?

I am actually surprisingly talented at being rejected, blamed, or insulted (thanks to a lifetime of conditioning, as above). What is far more difficult to handle is the feeling of guilt and shame afterwards - the rejection of myself.

Knowing someone is angry with me makes me feel like the worst human being to have ever graced this planet. It doesn't matter if it's a stranger who has shouted at me after bumping into me, or someone who is justifiably annoyed at something I've done.

The feeling of causing upset in anybody else is unbearable, because it is not controllable - although I will try my best, doing anything I can to try and fix it. Annoyingly, I assume that everybody else reacts this way too, which makes me avoid anything that could ever make them think I am angry at them, instead internalising this on myself. (Tip: they really don't.)

19. Do you give someone the benefit of the doubt even when others tell you this person is trouble?

Of course. The underdog is irresistible, reflecting back to me all of the ways that I have been misunderstood, excluded, and rejected from society over the years. I will be their friend!

This is not a particularly helpful trait to have. Time after time, I am proved wrong: they are not 'just misunderstood' - they do not care. This does remain a trait I am proud to have, in seeing the best in people, but I have learned over time that it is not my responsibility to save them.

People can be both 'trouble' and 'inherently good' - but it doesn't mean they deserve to be in my life.

20. Do you give people another chance even when they continue with the same hurtful or inappropriate behaviour?

Yes. This is complicated further by the annoying part of ADHD that means I often immediately forget any boundaries we have miraculously set about their treatment of me. At the grand age of 32, I have just about learned to 'set a boundary' - but upholding it is far more difficult.

As someone said to me, 'inspect what you expect.' I really, really hate doing this. I hate having to check if someone has actually followed through with the change they said they would do, because I don't want to have to go through the whole situation again and blame them, when they've already been so nice! They said they would try their best! So why am I being such a micromanager?

Autism further complicates this, because how are we supposed to know if they continue with the same exact behaviours? There is no timeline of when someone is supposed to change. One instance of hurtful behaviour, like lying, might be very different to another. Do we keep a LIST? Do we set SMART goals for them? How many 'chances' do we give them? What if they've tried in other ways? It's far easier to ignore reality all together.

21. Do you tell yourself that you don’t have a right to complain about a person’s behaviour if you’ve ever been guilty of the same behaviour?

This one hits a nerve. YES. I feel like anything negative I have ever done gives anybody else a perfectly valid reason for doing the same thing. Who am I to hold them to account?

Worse still, the hyper-empathy linked with autism means that I have a template ready for any such scenario. I understand their anguish and motives, because I've been there myself. Except, as I am continually learning, most people do not think like I do. Making a mistake does not condemn you to a lifetime sentence of excusing other people's mistakes.

22. Are you attracted to bad boys or people with a large dark side?

Well, when someone I'd been dating for a couple of weeks told me he was previously a heroin addict, my response may as well have been, 'I would have been disappointed if you weren't! How amazing! Do tell me all about it.' I moved in his house a few weeks later, during the global pandemic, and discovered that maybe I should have asked better questions.

I then went on to date someone who literally emotionally blackmailed me into dating them. They were such obvious 'bad news' that a friend sent me an exasperated text, asking what the hell I was doing. I defended them sharply, my sense of justice coming out. Everybody deserves a chance. The friend was indeed correct, a fact I only accepted a year later after having been through one of the worst psychological experiences of my life.

This is the danger of being AuDHD - we feel bad for people. People who wear their toxicity on their sleeve are like a lighthouse. They need help! We can help them, and lose all sense of ourselves. They offer the perfect set up: someone who will continually blame us for everything, reaffirming everything we already believe about ourselves.

Autism comes in especially annoyingly here. Big red flags about a person manifest like guiding lights on an airport runway. They tell us what to expect. Navigating personal relationships is an utter minefield, especially so in 'healthy' ones where nothing is clearly expected of us. Those relationships become harder to maintain, in place of ones where our role is so much clearer.

In dating situations, we also have the benefit of socially prescribed templates. It was only writing AuDHD: Blooming Differently that I understood why I have moved in with so many partners so quickly. I hate the anxiety of the 'dating stage', the excruciating uncertainty of what you 'are' and whether the person still likes you or not.

Moving in together removes this benchmark, leaving others that are easier to control. It's a terrible anchor, as the assumption is that we're safer in that relationship because we live together, and know what they're doing all of the time. The reality is that we're stuck, having handed over our independence to someone we probably do not know very well.

One good life lesson I've learned is that if someone wants to live with me a few weeks after knowing me, it is probably not a healthy relationship. Another is, 'when someone shows you who they are - believe them'.

23. Do you strongly believe in being fair even when other people are treating you unfairly?

Of course. This is the antidote to a kinder world - forgiveness and 'being the bigger person' (see Exhibit B: Donald Trump). Fighting hate with hate only results in really long annoying arguments where we inevitably blame ourselves, anyway.

Being fair to those who treat us unfairly feels like a sense of control in an otherwise uncontrollable situation. The only person we can control is ourselves.

Over time, I have learned that this is true, but it doesn't have to mean that we take responsibility for their actions. Being fair is not the same as being 'nice'. You can be fair whilst saying no, or setting (and enforcing!) a boundary.

RESULTS

The book says that if you answered yes to...

  • 2 or more of these questions, you have some Nice Girl in you.
  • 5 or more of these questions, you still have some work to do in terms of changing how you view yourself in the world.
  • 10 or more of these questions, then you have an extreme version of the Nice Girl syndrome and will need to do some serious work to rid yourself of the negative and false beliefs that are basically dictating your life.

When a therapist asked me to list the people I cared about in my life, she commented that I didn't even mention myself. I didn't even think to do so. My programming is wired to believe that caring about myself means being selfish and mean. What is actually 'broken' is the belief that if I am nice to other people, they will be nice to me.

Annoyingly, life continues to serve me the same patterns again and again until I rewire this programming. I repeat the pattern of ignoring all potential problems until I explode in anger, blaming myself, ripping everything up, and starting again.

What I am happy to report is that through discovering books like this, and accessing support, I have been able to stop internalising this anger so deeply. For years, I couldn't figure out why I was so suicidal. Now I look back and understand exactly why: I wasn't actually being as 'nice' as I thought I was - I was lying to myself, and everybody around me, living a life I hated.

As Beverly Engel says, Nice Girls are more likely to:

  • become victimised - emotionally, physically, and sexually - than those who are not so nice (side note: 9 out of 10 autistic women have been victims of sexual violence)
  • be taken advantage of, cheated on, abuse, or abandoned by their partners, thanks to giving others the benefit of the doubt
  • be targets for attackers, as they tend to be focused on others rather than protecting themselves or their safety
  • be taken for granted, over-worked, underpaid, and passed over for promotion.
  • feel lonely, as people don't really know you unless you tell them how you feel
  • feel guilty, as if you don't tell people how you honestly feel, you are being dishonest - and struggle to have intimacy as a result
  • put up with unacceptable behaviour for so long that they finally blow - overcompensating by being super nice to the person in future.

If this resonates with you, I strongly recommend reading Beverley's book, and seeking support. This is the very basis of our AuDHD Paradox Coaching Framework - not helping people to fit into society, but helping them to reconnect to themselves.

If we don't understand our own needs, it's impossible to communicate them to others. If we don't freely choose relationships that feel good, it's natural that all socialising will feel like running a marathon. If we don't trust our own emotions, it's impossible to stand up for ourselves.

If we don't trust, respect and honour our own instincts, like sensory overwhelm, we will constantly be blaming ourselves for being 'too sensitive'. If we don't understand our unique vulnerabilities as a result of being neurodivergent, we remain exposed to others who can see, target, and exploit these.

If we don't stand up for ourselves, we can't expect anybody else to. As we live in a world where women's rights, sanity and agency are under very real attack at an unimaginable rate, most recently to take perfectly safe pain killers during pregnancy (conveniently meaning they wouldn't be able to focus on anything but severe pain for 9 months), this has never been more important.

This is undoing a lifetime of conditioning, including from our capitalist society that profits off our insecurities. There is no magic pill or solution that can rewire your neurological pathways, but you can surround yourself with people who remind you that you are not broken.

Just yesterday, when I was in exactly the same hole, my AuDHD therapist Catherine Asta reminded me that my intuition is actually always right. She reminded me that just because I've experienced trauma before, doesn't mean that I am overreacting. With that single conversation, I realised that this trauma has all given me a very useful and accurate sense of when something is off - and I can trust it.

Although I have very clearly said in this that the same can apply to men, I can still near guarantee that I will receive at least one message from a man telling me how unfair I am being, and how they too have been abused by women. There is no binary here: if these symptoms resonate with you, they resonate with you. Welcome to the Nice Girl Club.

However, I will finish off with a reminder that your body cannot be used to bring another human being into this world. You don't have to worry every time you go outside that you'll be attacked (and then obviously, immediately guilty for even assuming you're worthy of even being attacked). You don't have to walk home with your keys sticking out of your fingers.

Men have their own struggles of 'niceness' - I am constantly coaching them on overcoming their own brand of shame for being a man at all in a world where violence against women and girls dominates the news.

Boys are conditioned to disconnect from their emotions and be 'tough', and girls are taught to disconnect from their bodies, and be 'nice'. The only time I see men cry without shame is during football matches - after which domestic violence rates increase.

When our national team wins a match, domestic violence incidents increase by 26%. If they lose, it increases by 38%. Regardless of the outcome, it increases by 11% the day after. In a world where men are shamed for being 'weak', due to the innately human experience of having feelings, is it any wonder that they take it out on the women who are allowed to cry?

As an ex-boyfriend once told me, as tears threatened to fill his eyes, 'it triggered me when you said you felt pressured, because I've been accused of rape before.' I almost burst out laughing, so disarmed that we ended up somehow getting onto the topic of abortion, which he didn't believe in. I reminded him that he doesn't actually have a choice.

'That's not fair!' he said, angrily googling 'can men stop women from having abortions' as he flushed with rage. 'It's my human right!!!'

Back then, as he discovered, women had full autonomy over whether they choose to procreate with someone like him. Today, this is a different story for women living in America.

If you have managed to read until the end of this, then I hope it was helpful. For once, I am not going to shorten it to be 'readable', because daring to take up space is not a terrible thing. Using our voice empowers others to do the same. And you deserve to exist without feeling guilty for it.

P.S - I would also strongly recommend coming to Dr Samantha Hiew's Neurodivergent Phoenix Convention, on 6th October, which I see as essentially an uprising for 'Nice Girls Who Have Been Called Crazy And Want The Science To Prove That They're Not The Problem'.

P.P.S - you can also learn the skills to empower others - and most importantly, yourself - in November by becoming an Advanced AuDHD Coach.


Want support that works with your brain?

Answer 6 questions to be matched with an ADHD Works trained coach, or train to become one yourself.

Find your match Become a coach
Previous
Previous

Trump's Cause of Autism: WOMEN! (AKA mothers who can't 'tough it out')

Next
Next

5 Ways To Handle People Who Don't Believe in ADHD (Without Losing Your Mind)