Externally, I look like a compulsive people-pleaser workaholic, who always seems to get things done - whether thats publishing a book, launching a course, or helping a friend (or stranger).
On the inside, I've spent my whole life feeling like the laziest person alive.
This is thanks to Pathological Demand Avoidance (also called 'Persistent Drive for Autonomy'). PDA is an autistic 'profile', essentially meaning that some autistic people may experience intense overwhelm and resistance towards everyday demands. This is even if they want to do them, for the sheer reason that they have to.
It's not a choice - it feels like having your brain battle against itself over every single task, even when you want to do it.
For example, since testing positive for covid this week, I have been unable to do the very thing I want and very much need to do: have a shower. There's zero explanation, other than a brain that loops endlessly on an hourly basis in a very boring monologue on the pros and cons of having a shower now or later (later always wins).
The PDA Society lists these traits of PDA:
- Avoiding the everyday demands of life, even things someone needs or wants to do.e.g extreme stress & anxiety in response to 'routine' daily activities
- Having a sociable relationship style which can mask deeper challenges. e.gbeing able to make friends, but not keep them due to unclear longer-term expectations
- Using social strategies as part of this avoidance. e.g changing the subject, distracting others with humour or questions, avoidance, or zoning out
- Intense emotions and mood swings. e.g experiencing meltdowns as a result of stress build up
There isn't much research on PDA, but ask any parent of a neurodivergent child, and you'll likely see instant recognition. Getting a child with PDA to do something they don't want to do, like brushing their teeth, might feel like a daily marathon for everybody involved.
Here's what it's like for me:
Demands Everywhere
PDA can relate to any demand, including those we actually want to do. For me, this is whenever there's an expectation - either from myself or others. Some of the 'demands' I have struggled with throughout my life include:
- Being alive - the basic expectations of breathing, thinking, and living in general have often resulted in suicidal ideation - not because of specific circumstances, but because of the lack of control.
- Self-care - cooking, cleaning, showering, leaving the house, brushing my teeth, going to the doctor, 'resting' and taking holidays are all fraught with ruminative cycles about how they 'should' happen. Annoyingly, acts of self-neglect can make me feel like I have some sense of control.
- Making decisions - such as about what to wear, say to a stranger, do on a weekend, where to meet, or virtually anything else can leave me in paralysis.
- Relationships - choosing and maintaining friendships, navigating group events, arranging meet ups, navigating small talk and 'catching up' can all feel like obstacle courses.
- 'Celebrations' - celebrating my own or someone else's birthday, Christmas, Easter, 'achievements' and milestones - all come with their own unique form of pressure and overwhelm in not knowing how to 'be'.
- Administration - responding to messages, paying bills, organising travel and keeping receipts - the list is endless, and all of these things have the potential to melt my brain.
Whenever I try to do any of these tasks, I am faced with an overwhelm of thoughts and potential scenarios. One thought leads to another: how long 'should' I do this for? What 'should' I do? Am I doing it right? Should I do this now or later? Do I even want to do this? Do I actually need to do it? Why should I?
Autistic people tend to process information 'bottom-up', meaning that we may process demands through (imagined) external perspectives, rather than our own. For example, if someone asks me directly to do something, even if I don't want to do it, I have no idea how to say 'no', because I know they expect me to say yes.
This is complicated by a brain that processes literally. If I'm asked if I can do something, I will say yes before even realising that I don't want to. We can do anything, but not everything!
All of this has a significant impact on our ability to trust ourselves, which is already impacted through impacted executive functioning skills of self-awareness. These situations can feel so exhausting that we may find it easier to simply 'do' the task, than try to honour our own resistance.
We might have conditioned ourselves to ignore those feelings as 'laziness', trusting other people's perspectives and expectations above our own. For me, this has meant being in several toxic relationships, for the simple fact that these people were at least clear about what they wanted from me. This felt much easier than the mental gymnastics of trying to figure it out.
The Concept of Expectations
PDA is often not even about the demand itself. It's about the expectation related to it, both from ourselves and others.
Ironically, my coping strategies have included hyper-compliance, saying yes to absolutely everything, and replying to everything immediately. If I don't do it immediately, then it will become an expectation - an open 'tab' in my brain that I will think about constantly and beat myself up about until it's done.
This might look productive, but it's also extremely unproductive if you are burning yourself out and constantly prioritising other people over yourself.
Challenges around expectations can arise in a few different ways, including:
- Planning: with a brain perceiving time as 'now or not now', it might feel easier to simply mask by saying 'yes' immediately to any future requests, just to get rid of the immediate expectation. This usually results in having to cancel later on!
- Functioning: as soon as something becomes an expectation, I will try to avoid it. This is most annoying for me with things like DIY - instead of just reading the instructions, I will just half-make it before giving up and living surrounded by boxes and furniture for weeks on end. This fuels generally rushing into things and doing them immediately, because I have no idea if the motivation will be there tomorrow.
- Goals: I've always found it impossible to set goals without knowing the full context (like picking a career path at 18 without experiencing any careers!). This is why we train coaches to use ADHD & AuDHD frameworks for coaching as an 'optional menu' - because how are we supposed to know what we need help with if we don't know what we're dealing with?
- Pressure: our brains may work in 'all or nothing' states, meaning that once we start a task, we know we won't be able to just do that part. Rejection Sensitive Dysphoria may also show up to remind us that we're probably not going to do it right. This might result in avoidance, masking, or burnout - even if it's 'only' self-imposed.
- Being perceived: as we're constantly searching for patterns from other people, we might unconsciously try to 'mind read', predicting the perspectives of everybody around us before being able to identify with what we want. This can also result in difficulties committing, as we may be hyper-aware of 'boxing ourselves in', when we know we're likely to get bored!
- Seeking or accepting help: the thought of asking for help is incredibly stressful, sparking all sorts of anxiety about what this 'means', feeling guilty, what to even ask for, shame, and the inevitable crash of feelings if we dare to 'put ourselves out there' and don't receive it. This is why being unwell is extremely triggering for me: it's a reminder of my own human vulnerability.
How to cope
If PDA is something you experience, the below might help:
- Learn about PDA - you are not insane / lazy / dramatic / attention seeking etc - your brain is simply wired for autonomy, like a zebra vs a horse.
- Be nice to yourself - this doesn't look like bubble baths - it might look like eating ice cream for breakfast, and that's perfectly fine. Life is hard enough without beating yourself up all the time!
- Set end points - asking yourself 'how will I know when I'm done?' can break down demands and give yourself a flexible structure for day to day living.
- Give yourself options - sometimes it is just easier to take 3 extra outfits with you rather than have a meltdown about what to wear. Do what works for you!
- Set 'minimum' goals - identify the 'easiest possible scenario'. For example, when my personal trainer asked what my fitness goals were, I said, 'leave the house'. It worked (until it didn't anymore - and that's okay!).
- Find people who accept you as you are - they are out there. This means people who ideally understand PDA and aren't trying to control you. My brilliant therapist Catherine Asta helped me to reframe my own unhealthy coping strategies this week as just that - coping strategies. (Our trained Advanced AuDHD coaches are also a great place to start!)
- Appoint a decision maker (with caution): ChatGPT is extraordinarily helpful for 'small' decisions, like what to eat for dinner - but just as with humans, outsourcing your autonomy can result in codependent relationships. However, if there's someone in your life who 'gets' PDA and who you trust to help you make quick choices, please don't feel shame about seeking support.
- Release expectations - you don't need to 'reach your full potential' or 'find your purpose' or 'have a shower' if you don't want to. Ultimately, you are a human being, and the world won't fall down if you don't go to the gym at 6am (or at all).
- Trust yourself - you are reading this right now, which means you can trust yourself to keep yourself alive - you've done so up until now! You are not defined by what you do - you are enough exactly as you are.
- Listen to yourself - taking time to reflect on your own thoughts and feelings can be really helpful to understand your own wants and needs. You are likely very different from who you were 10 years ago, but you're still you.
Remember: you're not lazy! It's ironic that we may beat ourselves up all of the time for being lazy when our brains are constantly engaged. 'Most' people do not have the same overwhelm and exhaustion in being bombarded with thoughts, expectations, and other people's perspectives every time they try to do a task.
If you have a loved one with PDA (parents, I am particularly thinking of you here!), this might help:
- Provide autonomy - when you want them to do something, try saying their name (helpful to cut through the loud inner thoughts!) and ask them a question. Framing this as a choice instead of a demand can have a significant difference.
- Explain the 'why' - context helps us to feel agency in terms of being essentially treated like an equal, instead of hearing 'because I said so!'
- Be specific (especially about the end point) - your loved one is also not a mind reader. Instead of saying 'lay the table', being specific about what it is exactly that you want (e.g 'X, please can you put the plates on the table?') will help the other person to accurately process this request.
- Talk to them about PDA -we can call this 'name it to tame it'. Understanding how your loved one processes 'demands' will be the most helpful thing you can do, because you can collaborate based on their unique needs, as opposed to working against each other.
- 'Let them' -this might feel uncomfortable, but sometimes the best way to learn is through making mistakes. For example, when I was burgled as a teenager I had to explain to the horrified police how the robbers hadn't trashed my bedroom - this was embarrassing enough to make me clean it! This book explains the concept very well.
- Prioritise yourself - I have worked with many parents who've been on the receiving end of violence and/or extreme aggression from children with PDA. If this is you, please know that it has zero reflection on your parenting abilities, and you have to put your own oxygen mask on first - literally. Accessing support (such as PDA / AuDHD peer groups, coaching or therapy) for yourself can make a huge difference.
- Offer external support to your loved one - whilst things like AuDHD coaching can be exceptionally helpful for people with PDA, especially for children in providing them with an adult who's not a 'doctor' or their family to talk to, they have to want to do it. Many children I've spoken to were being encouraged coaching by their parents, but reminding them that it's completely up to them is absolutely crucial for them to engage with this effectively - if at all.
- Remove pressure and expectations - although it can be really difficult if you disagree with your loved one's choices (like not brushing their teeth!), ultimately, it's their life. Seeing these as coping strategies, as opposed to any reflection of how they feel about you, and releasing pressure is extremely effective reverse psychology!