It's ironic that in the week of 'International Women's Day', autism researcher Dame Uta Frith dismissed the experiences of hundreds of thousands of autistic women. Apparently, the 'spectrum' has become too inclusive.
When this is understood in context, these comments can be explained - but not excused. Here's why:
1) The 1980s model of autism Frith champions is ABOUT autistic people - not WITH us
Frith helped to develop the 'Theory of Mind' framework in the 1980s - the idea that autistic people struggle to understand that others have different thoughts and feelings. Essentially, the theory that 'autistic people lack empathy'.
Of course, the 3 researchers (Uta Frith, Simon Baron-Cohen, & Alan Leslie) who designed this model would agree on a common understanding of empathy that autistic people do not share, because they are neurotypical.
In 2012, Damian Milton (who crucially, is autistic himself), developed a framework called the Double Empathy Problem. This essentially says that the communication breakdown between neurotypical and neurodivergent people is mutual - the empathy challenges go both ways. It's just that we don't study or blame neurotypical people for it.
Together, autistic people showed high rapport and connection - it was the mixed neurotype pairs that struggled the most. Essentially - the deficit is not in the autistic person - it's in the mismatch, and in who gets to define what 'normal' looks like.
The idea that autistic people lack empathy has been further disproved by 78% of autistic people identifying as hyper-empathetic in one study. This can result in absorbing other people's emotions to the point of overwhelm.
Frith's Theory of Mind failed to distinguish between affective (emotional) and cognitive empathy, the latter of which involves processing social cues in real time (and may be better linked with alexithymia - challenges identifying our own feelings).
Her recent comments highlighted this 'about vs with' us tension, criticising current assessment methods for relying on a patient’s 'subjective experience, rather than on objective clinical observation.' According to her, not enough attention is paid to 'telltale signs of autism, such as conversation feeling stilted or abrupt, or whether the person can read between the lines in a conversation and get irony and humour'.
Essentially, she is saying that neurotypicals should be the ones who get to decide whether a person is autistic - we can't just invite ourselves to the party.
2) The Nazi-era interpretation of autism Frith is known for was never built for girls (or women)
Much of Frith's influence in autism research stems from her 1991 translation of Hans Asperger's original 1944 paper, bringing his work to the English-speaking world for the first time.
Asperger was a paediatrician working in Vienna under the Nazi regime. His job was to assess children and decide who was 'redeemable' - whose life was valuable enough to protect. The children celebrated in his paper were 4 boys presented as his 'little professors': intelligent, intensely focused, socially unusual but gifted.
The children who didn't fit that mould, including many girls, who tended to present very differently, were referred to Am Spiegelgrund, a clinic where over 700 children were killed under the Nazi eugenics programme.
This remained largely unknown to the English-speaking world until 2018, when historian Edith Sheffer published Asperger's Children, exposing the full extent of Asperger's Nazi collaboration - 74 years after the paper, and 27 years after Frith's full academic translation.
By then, 'Asperger's syndrome' had already been removed from the DSM in 2013. The reason for this was inconsistent application between 'autism' and 'Asperger's' between doctors, and the fact that it had become synonymous with 'high functioning' and therefore 'productive'.
As Gina Rippon's excellent book explains, the entire history of autism is based on boys, and defined by neurotypicals. The filter of Nazi-era ideas about social usefulness that Frith amplified haven't disappeared - they just exist in a different form today, such as RFK Jr saying autistic people 'will never pay taxes, never hold a job, never have a relationship'.
This diagnostic model was never built for girls - or women. It was never built for people who learned to survive by hiding their symptoms.
So through this lens, it's clearer how Frith believes it has become 'too inclusive'. Of course she rejected the notion that girls and women were being undiagnosed - we were never meant to fit into her idea of autism.
3) Pathologising neurodivergence results in deficit based 'disorders' - not differences
Dame Uta Frith says 'what's notable about being a part of a huge spectrum that we all belong to? We’re all neurodiverse; we can accept this because all our brains are different. But it makes a medical diagnosis completely meaningless.'
This is the exact issue with neurodevelopmental differences being categorised through a psychiatry model, and gate-kept behind years-long waiting lists for 'specialist' assessments. For example, despite a 50-70% crossover of ADHD & autism, an AuDHD individual's presentation of symptoms may not meet one or even both of these diagnostic criteria threshold, as they may cancel each other out.
They shouldn't need to fit into a pre-defined box, or have a medical diagnosis of a 'disorder' or 'deficit' to access understanding and support from our society. This is exactly why I made the Neuroaffirmative Supervision course - because the reality of working and engaging with fellow human beings doesn't care about labels.
Research suggests between 89-97% of autistic people over the age of 40–60 are undiagnosed, but this doesn't stop them from existing. It just means that they're likely misunderstood by other people as well as themselves.
Just because these people have evolved and adapted to cope with their symptoms to the extent that they may not have ended up in a psychiatrist's office, doesn't mean that they are not autistic. Frith argues that there's 'no scientific basis' for masking, despite a LOT of it being very easily accessible on Google.
Again, this makes sense through Frith's understanding of autism, which she'd still call a 'disorder'.
4) Empathy, support, & acceptance are not finite resources
In recent interviews, Dame Uta suggested that there's now 'two big subgroups' of autism: those diagnosed in early childhood (under 5), and those diagnosed later in life, who she suggested could be called 'hypersensitive'.
This latter group is apparently made up of a lot of adolescents, particularly young women, 'without intellectual impairment, who are perfectly able to communicate verbally and non-verbally, but who might feel highly anxious in social situations'. Apparently this group is growing at a 'frightening rate', as opposed to a 'moderate increase' in the first, for whom she'd fight for the label of autism to be limited for.
I'm not sure what's so frightening about people accessing support, especially those who have historically been excluded, but then again, I am autistic.
What feels more frightening to me is how groups of people are classified as 'disordered' for being seen as different.
Ironically, the people who seem to have the biggest problem with 'labels' and neurodiversity are neurotypical people. Whether an individual has self-identified as autistic or ADHD, or received a formal diagnosis from a professional qualified according to neurotypical standards, makes no difference to me.
I will still treat them with the same respect, dignity, and compassion as I would a neurotypical person. There are different autistic people with different experiences and needs - and arbitrary divisions serve nobody except a society that benefits from difference being stigmatised as a 'disorder'. We need more resources, not fewer diagnoses.
If people like Dame Uta Frith believe that the interpretation of autism today has become 'too inclusive', then instead accusing people of 'self-diagnosing and putting pressure on doctors to diagnose them', maybe the question needs to be: why? Why do people want the label she says is meaningless?
This is especially against a backdrop of a medical world where it's commonly accepted that there's 'no treatment for autism' (from a pharmacological perspective) - and a societal history where a diagnosis equates to life-threatening persecution.
The only clear clinical utility I've seen from this label is categorising people as 'useful' or 'not useful' to society. Just as I wouldn't use a wheelchair if I didn't need one, people who do not need this label will not seek it out - the question worth asking is why so many people are desperately trying to access a label that comes with so little practical support attached to it.
The answer isn't that they're self-diagnosing for fun. It's that finally having a word for your experiences - after decades of being told you're broken, lazy, difficult, too much - is worth more than any clinical intervention. The label isn't meaningless, but traditional support, provided through a neurotypical lens, so often is.
The spectrum being broad doesn't mean one person's struggles cancel out another's. It means autism looks genuinely different in different people. A late-diagnosed woman who held down a job while quietly falling apart inside isn't taking anything away from a non-verbal child who needs round the clock support.
The real enemy isn't each other - it's the lack of support for everyone in a society that measures human worth by productivity and compliance with the status quo.